| fight between two pilots 10:50 - Sep 30 with 1106 views | giant_stow |
on a plane - saw this on Twitter earlier and wrote it off as Twitter-bollox:
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/liv
Edit: it actually sounds more like attempted murder / possible hijacking.
[Post edited 30 Sep 10:51]
|  |
| |  |
| fight between two pilots on 10:59 - Sep 30 with 1056 views | Steve_M |
Something clearly happened to force an emergency landing.
As evidenced in the last three days though, a lot of people will just make any old sh1t up for clicks. Which is they this is a 'live blog' rather than just a story that gets updated when anything significant gets released. |  |
| |
| fight between two pilots on 11:48 - Sep 30 with 935 views | DanTheMan |
| fight between two pilots on 10:59 - Sep 30 by Steve_M |
Something clearly happened to force an emergency landing.
As evidenced in the last three days though, a lot of people will just make any old sh1t up for clicks. Which is they this is a 'live blog' rather than just a story that gets updated when anything significant gets released. |
Looks like something happened between the co-pilot and pilot, with the co-pilot trying to crash the plane and stab the pilot.
Then the passengers helped subdue the co-pilot and some other medically trained passengers helped with the wounded.
They plummeted like 15,000 feet in one minute. I cannot imagine how terrifying that was for the passengers - very brave of some of them to get involve and save the people on board. |  |
| |
| fight between two pilots on 12:01 - Sep 30 with 876 views | mellowblue |
| fight between two pilots on 11:48 - Sep 30 by DanTheMan |
Looks like something happened between the co-pilot and pilot, with the co-pilot trying to crash the plane and stab the pilot.
Then the passengers helped subdue the co-pilot and some other medically trained passengers helped with the wounded.
They plummeted like 15,000 feet in one minute. I cannot imagine how terrifying that was for the passengers - very brave of some of them to get involve and save the people on board. |
Lucky also that 2 pilots were in the back seats on a transfer so could step in to land the plane. |  | | |
| fight between two pilots on 12:02 - Sep 30 with 875 views | TIB |
Just watched the FR24 and ADSB flight data back, that plane went nose down for maybe 15-30secs from looks of it.
A6-FKF for anyone interested. |  |
| |
| fight between two pilots on 13:19 - Sep 30 with 687 views | Steve_M |
| fight between two pilots on 12:02 - Sep 30 by TIB |
Just watched the FR24 and ADSB flight data back, that plane went nose down for maybe 15-30secs from looks of it.
A6-FKF for anyone interested. |
That it dropped that far would probably account for the damage:
A photo showing damage to the tail of FlyDubai Flight 1073 incurred during it's rapid descent. — Faytuks Network (@faytuksnetwork.bsky.social) 2026-09-30T10:11:46.586298+00:00
| |
| |
| fight between two pilots on 13:19 - Sep 30 with 675 views | Illinoisblue |
| fight between two pilots on 12:02 - Sep 30 by TIB |
Just watched the FR24 and ADSB flight data back, that plane went nose down for maybe 15-30secs from looks of it.
A6-FKF for anyone interested. |
Just said on news here it dropped 17,000 feet in two minutes. That’ll wake you up from your nap. |  |
| |
| fight between two pilots on 13:35 - Sep 30 with 603 views | baxterbasics |
| fight between two pilots on 11:48 - Sep 30 by DanTheMan |
Looks like something happened between the co-pilot and pilot, with the co-pilot trying to crash the plane and stab the pilot.
Then the passengers helped subdue the co-pilot and some other medically trained passengers helped with the wounded.
They plummeted like 15,000 feet in one minute. I cannot imagine how terrifying that was for the passengers - very brave of some of them to get involve and save the people on board. |
Reminiscent of United 93 - only with a happier ending. There was a passenger that day with flying experience too that could potentially have landed if they'd been able to wrestle control back in time. But they were already too low to the ground once Ziad Jarrah put the plane into a dive.
I'd imagine after the example of that flight, passengers today will be quicker to get involved if there's an incursion in the cockpit. |  |
| |
| fight between two pilots on 13:35 - Sep 30 with 604 views | Guthrum |
Blimey, they lost the rudder. That would make ordinary banked turns very difficult. Control in the yaw axis would have to be managed by varying the engine thrust on each side, neither rapid response nor precise. Plus the missing weight would give the aircraft a nose-down trim, which can be compensated for a bit with tailplane settings and shifting fuel about, but not ideal.
I imagine it would prevent them using the autopilot or landing systems after the incident. |  |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| fight between two pilots on 13:37 - Sep 30 with 589 views | giant_stow |
| fight between two pilots on 13:35 - Sep 30 by Guthrum |
Blimey, they lost the rudder. That would make ordinary banked turns very difficult. Control in the yaw axis would have to be managed by varying the engine thrust on each side, neither rapid response nor precise. Plus the missing weight would give the aircraft a nose-down trim, which can be compensated for a bit with tailplane settings and shifting fuel about, but not ideal.
I imagine it would prevent them using the autopilot or landing systems after the incident. |
Blimey, looking like the people on that plane had many individual slices of luck. | |
| |
| fight between two pilots on 13:53 - Sep 30 with 545 views | Guthrum |
| fight between two pilots on 13:35 - Sep 30 by baxterbasics |
Reminiscent of United 93 - only with a happier ending. There was a passenger that day with flying experience too that could potentially have landed if they'd been able to wrestle control back in time. But they were already too low to the ground once Ziad Jarrah put the plane into a dive.
I'd imagine after the example of that flight, passengers today will be quicker to get involved if there's an incursion in the cockpit. |
With United 93, the hijackers put the 'plane into a very steep and (at least eventually) inverted dive. There was no realistic chance of pulling out of that. Aerodynamic forces would likely have torn the aircraft apart. | |
| |
| fight between two pilots on 13:53 - Sep 30 with 550 views | Kievthegreat |
| fight between two pilots on 13:35 - Sep 30 by Guthrum |
Blimey, they lost the rudder. That would make ordinary banked turns very difficult. Control in the yaw axis would have to be managed by varying the engine thrust on each side, neither rapid response nor precise. Plus the missing weight would give the aircraft a nose-down trim, which can be compensated for a bit with tailplane settings and shifting fuel about, but not ideal.
I imagine it would prevent them using the autopilot or landing systems after the incident. |
It would remove traditional yaw control (like you said, you can use individual engine control as a substitute). However the aircraft would still be stable in Yaw so will naturally return to straight. Providing the pilots gently ease into any banking manoeuvre, that would probably be enough to keep it stable. Pain will be trying to make small adjustments on approach with lots of lag between changing thrust and actually getting the reaction on the aircraft.
It also suggests that in addition to a steep dive there must have been some big yaw forces to rip the rudder control surface clean off as I doubt speed alone would be enough. Would have been terrifying to be onboard. |  | | |
| fight between two pilots on 14:11 - Sep 30 with 497 views | mellowblue |
| fight between two pilots on 13:37 - Sep 30 by giant_stow |
Blimey, looking like the people on that plane had many individual slices of luck. |
Massive amount of luck.
If the co-pilot had overridden the entry lock pad in the passenger/cabin crew section, there would have been no opportunity to enter the flight crew cabin and intervene. Which makes me think it might have been a genuine fight rather than a wish to crash the plane. Otherwise the order of events should have been, make sure the flight deck could not be entered, kill the pilot, crash the plane. | | | |
| fight between two pilots on 14:49 - Sep 30 with 392 views | ElderGrizzly |
| fight between two pilots on 14:11 - Sep 30 by mellowblue |
Massive amount of luck.
If the co-pilot had overridden the entry lock pad in the passenger/cabin crew section, there would have been no opportunity to enter the flight crew cabin and intervene. Which makes me think it might have been a genuine fight rather than a wish to crash the plane. Otherwise the order of events should have been, make sure the flight deck could not be entered, kill the pilot, crash the plane. |
Pilots shouldn’t be able to take anything that can be used to stab a fellow pilot into the cockpit.
Reports are co-pilot stabbed captain. It’s not ‘just a fight’ in that situation. It means there are failures in security within the airport too. Either intentional or not. [Post edited 30 Sep 14:50]
|  | | |
| fight between two pilots on 15:15 - Sep 30 with 304 views | Guthrum |
| fight between two pilots on 13:53 - Sep 30 by Kievthegreat |
It would remove traditional yaw control (like you said, you can use individual engine control as a substitute). However the aircraft would still be stable in Yaw so will naturally return to straight. Providing the pilots gently ease into any banking manoeuvre, that would probably be enough to keep it stable. Pain will be trying to make small adjustments on approach with lots of lag between changing thrust and actually getting the reaction on the aircraft.
It also suggests that in addition to a steep dive there must have been some big yaw forces to rip the rudder control surface clean off as I doubt speed alone would be enough. Would have been terrifying to be onboard. |
Photo from another angle shows what looks like a trim tab still intact at the top of the stabiliser. Assuming it was still powered, that would give at least some aerodynamic yaw control. But still not so agile as the full rudder. | |
| |
| fight between two pilots on 15:16 - Sep 30 with 300 views | mellowblue |
| fight between two pilots on 14:49 - Sep 30 by ElderGrizzly |
Pilots shouldn’t be able to take anything that can be used to stab a fellow pilot into the cockpit.
Reports are co-pilot stabbed captain. It’s not ‘just a fight’ in that situation. It means there are failures in security within the airport too. Either intentional or not. [Post edited 30 Sep 14:50]
|
attack rather than fight. I was only quoting the earlier reports of a fight. Makes you wonder what security is like at some of the Asian airports that plane regularly visits. | | | |
| fight between two pilots on 15:25 - Sep 30 with 258 views | LandOfMickyStockwell |
This is very alarming and it would be good to know that the pilot that was attacked is OK. Fortunate not to have a major tragedy here.
Bringing this to an Ipswich Town perspective for a moment... do you think that Leif Davis is imagining himself in the shoes of the pilots having to recover the diving plane? They did a tremendous job, one reported as British too. Something best left for the safety of his simulator! |  | | |
| fight between two pilots on 16:10 - Sep 30 with 132 views | jontysnut |
The Red Baron or Douglas Bader? There's only only way to find out.... |  | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
