Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) 10:52 - Jan 28 with 3675 viewstonybied

1
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 11:57 - Jan 28Swansea_Blue

Hurray. I wouldn’t want to be sitting in the front row - there’s a good chance you’d be sent off by mistake.

Poll: Escaped Goat of the day. Who’s it going to be?

2
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 12:02 - Jan 28GlasgowBlue

Delap will need to be on his best behavior then.

Antisemites, Jew haters and crashing bores will be put on ignore.
Blog: [Blog] For the Sake of My Football Club, Please Go

0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 12:05 - Jan 28rickw

Maybe with what happened this means he won't want to give any soft sendings off this weekend?
Which probably means a Southampton player will get away with murder!!

Poll: Of the Non Favourites for ITFC managers job who would you prefer
Blog: Reasons for Relegation

1
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 12:11 - Jan 28Keno

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 12:05 - Jan 28 by rickw

Maybe with what happened this means he won't want to give any soft sendings off this weekend?
Which probably means a Southampton player will get away with murder!!


Like Pedro did for Brighton the other week?

Poll: With modern training etc which Town team would be best
Blog: [Blog] My World Cup Reflections

0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 14:45 - Jan 28Marshalls_Mullet

To be honest. Its easy for a ref to make a mistake, VAR was more at fault re that decision.

Poll: Would Lambert have acheived better results than Cook if given the same resources

3
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 14:59 - Jan 28Stewart27

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 14:45 - Jan 28 by Marshalls_Mullet

To be honest. Its easy for a ref to make a mistake, VAR was more at fault re that decision.


Sending a player off for tripping somebody over in front of him?
0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 15:02 - Jan 28SheffordBlue

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 14:45 - Jan 28 by Marshalls_Mullet

To be honest. Its easy for a ref to make a mistake, VAR was more at fault re that decision.


I think the "Refs Call" change they made this season has been largely a good thing with fewer subjective decisions being re-reffed by VAR. I think I'd still prefer the odd one to get through where they might have sent him to have another look than for every decision to be getting referred.

Poll: What % of our full potential are we currently playing at?

0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 15:22 - Jan 28SitfcB

Good, nice to have a decent ref.

Owes us a penalty as well.

COYB
Poll: Should we block polls for one day?
Blog: [Blog] One Year On

2
Login to get fewer ads

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 15:24 - Jan 28SitfcB

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 14:45 - Jan 28 by Marshalls_Mullet

To be honest. Its easy for a ref to make a mistake, VAR was more at fault re that decision.


Don’t get the OTT reaction to it tbh.

People have been calling for red cards for cynical fouls like that for ages, plus it was more than that, Lewis-Skelly raked his studs down the players leg a little bit, can see why it was a red.

COYB
Poll: Should we block polls for one day?
Blog: [Blog] One Year On

4
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 15:57 - Jan 28Marshalls_Mullet

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 14:59 - Jan 28 by Stewart27

Sending a player off for tripping somebody over in front of him?


Refs can make mistakes, you dont know how well he saw it, and the foot was high. It may have looked worse to him than it was.

VAR however, got to watch multiple replays in slow motion.

Poll: Would Lambert have acheived better results than Cook if given the same resources

0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 16:28 - Jan 28MattinLondon

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 14:59 - Jan 28 by Stewart27

Sending a player off for tripping somebody over in front of him?


Studs were high, on a players ankle and made no attempt whatsoever to play the ball. Was a cynical foul to prevent a breakaway.
1
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 16:41 - Jan 28Garv

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 15:24 - Jan 28 by SitfcB

Don’t get the OTT reaction to it tbh.

People have been calling for red cards for cynical fouls like that for ages, plus it was more than that, Lewis-Skelly raked his studs down the players leg a little bit, can see why it was a red.


Completely agree. Reaction well OTT.

Poll: By only voting with your head and not heart, will we stay up?

1
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 16:41 - Jan 28Nthsuffolkblue

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 15:24 - Jan 28 by SitfcB

Don’t get the OTT reaction to it tbh.

People have been calling for red cards for cynical fouls like that for ages, plus it was more than that, Lewis-Skelly raked his studs down the players leg a little bit, can see why it was a red.


I don't think the argument should be over whether he got it right or not as much as the fact that he needs fans' support over the ridiculous targeting of his family by at least one idiot. I think he should get a round of applause from all fans of both teams before the game as a mark of support. Without a referee there is no match.

As for the decision itself, there is enough disagreement that it is fine VAR didn't get involved. Personally, I think it was not a red as the rules currently stand but I have no problem with the rules making something like that a red card. It was so late that there was no doubt it was a cynical foul and that is something the game as an entertainment would benefit from having cut out.

Poll: Who is the greatest threat to the UK right now?
Blog: [Blog] Ghostbusters

3
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 16:57 - Jan 28tonybied

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 16:41 - Jan 28 by Nthsuffolkblue

I don't think the argument should be over whether he got it right or not as much as the fact that he needs fans' support over the ridiculous targeting of his family by at least one idiot. I think he should get a round of applause from all fans of both teams before the game as a mark of support. Without a referee there is no match.

As for the decision itself, there is enough disagreement that it is fine VAR didn't get involved. Personally, I think it was not a red as the rules currently stand but I have no problem with the rules making something like that a red card. It was so late that there was no doubt it was a cynical foul and that is something the game as an entertainment would benefit from having cut out.


Pretty much agree with your stance. It's not a red with how the laws currently stand. I think VAR really should've overturned personally as it wasn't dangerous, violent or out of control but that's not Oliver's issue. Why he's got pelters for it is beyond me.

I also think blatant cynical fouls like this should be punishable with a red, it's just another form of cheating that is massively prevalent in the game now and needs eradicating.
4
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 16:58 - Jan 28redrickstuhaart

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 16:57 - Jan 28 by tonybied

Pretty much agree with your stance. It's not a red with how the laws currently stand. I think VAR really should've overturned personally as it wasn't dangerous, violent or out of control but that's not Oliver's issue. Why he's got pelters for it is beyond me.

I also think blatant cynical fouls like this should be punishable with a red, it's just another form of cheating that is massively prevalent in the game now and needs eradicating.


It is a red. Studs up, half way up the calf.

Poll: Spectrum or C64 / Pablo or Kuqi- your preferences?

0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 17:04 - Jan 28Nthsuffolkblue

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 16:58 - Jan 28 by redrickstuhaart

It is a red. Studs up, half way up the calf.


And off the ball deliberately aimed at the player. As I said, I have no issue with VAR leaving the decision as it is.

I also don't think it is a sending off as the rules stand. I don't think it fits the description in the rules of serious foul play. The fact there is clear disagreement shows it is not clear cut for me at least.

Poll: Who is the greatest threat to the UK right now?
Blog: [Blog] Ghostbusters

0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 17:04 - Jan 28tonybied

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 16:58 - Jan 28 by redrickstuhaart

It is a red. Studs up, half way up the calf.


Not from my viewing. It was an intentional trip, freeze-framed shots make it look like a rake but that's not what it was if you watch it in real time.
0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 17:16 - Jan 28redrickstuhaart

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 17:04 - Jan 28 by tonybied

Not from my viewing. It was an intentional trip, freeze-framed shots make it look like a rake but that's not what it was if you watch it in real time.


Studs are up and make contact half way up the calf. Its a poor tackle, irrespective of the trip and entirely justifiable red on that basis.

Poll: Spectrum or C64 / Pablo or Kuqi- your preferences?

0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 18:22 - Jan 28SitfcB

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 16:58 - Jan 28 by redrickstuhaart

It is a red. Studs up, half way up the calf.


Rescinded.

Shocked at that.


COYB
Poll: Should we block polls for one day?
Blog: [Blog] One Year On

0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 18:34 - Jan 28MattinLondon

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 18:22 - Jan 28 by SitfcB

Rescinded.

Shocked at that.



Big club gets let off - shock and horror and all that.
0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 19:18 - Jan 28Stenvict

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 17:16 - Jan 28 by redrickstuhaart

Studs are up and make contact half way up the calf. Its a poor tackle, irrespective of the trip and entirely justifiable red on that basis.


Morsy's on Harry Wilson was worse, I'd say, but was never a red.

Poll: What will be announced first?

0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 21:55 - Jan 28Nthsuffolkblue

Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 18:22 - Jan 28 by SitfcB

Rescinded.

Shocked at that.



It does not hit the definition of serious foul play as the rules define it.

However, the deliberate intent to stop an opponent in such a position really shouldn't be punished with just a yellow card.

Poll: Who is the greatest threat to the UK right now?
Blog: [Blog] Ghostbusters

0
Michael Oliver reffing our game on Saturday (n/t) on 22:03 - Jan 28Bluesky

He’s a very good referee.
1
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2026