Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration 11:10 - Jun 20 with 1959 viewsHackneyblueboy

Shame as think he would have been absolutely ideal for the role.

We have to move forward with GON. I don't think it's a disastrous appointment myself but can see why people are a little disappointed.

In reality though when you look at the market there were not many standout candidates.
0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:13 - Jun 20Marshalls_Mullet

Why do people rate Corberan so highly? Very average record.

Poll: Would Lambert have acheived better results than Cook if given the same resources

4
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:13 - Jun 20TRUE_BLUE123

I really like Corberan. Would have been interesting.

Poll: Will Paul Lambert be Ipswich Town manager on the final day of this season ?

0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:16 - Jun 20Nutkins_Return

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:13 - Jun 20 by Marshalls_Mullet

Why do people rate Corberan so highly? Very average record.


Really agree. He's more of a Spanish Mick McCarthy as all about defensive solidity. He is a good coach but I've no interest trying to defend our way to safety. Joyless football. If he was called Frank Smith there would be no clamour for him at all.

As I say in the same way a McCarthy or a Dyche are good I fully respect him but not for me

Poll: Who do we think McKenna (not you) will partner Greaves with ?

0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:20 - Jun 20Churchman

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:13 - Jun 20 by Marshalls_Mullet

Why do people rate Corberan so highly? Very average record.


He’s got an exotic foreign name so he has to be good. I mean, anyone called Carlos can do no wrong. Just think Carlos Alberto, Roberto Carlos, Carlos Santana, Alcatraz the tennis dude.

Nailed on success. What on earth are they thinking employing a Gary?
2
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:25 - Jun 20SuffolkPunchFC

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:13 - Jun 20 by TRUE_BLUE123

I really like Corberan. Would have been interesting.


Other than being a 'foreign' manager, rather than a young English manager, I'm not sure what people see in Corberan. IMO he's not really shown credentials for being a top league manager.
0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:27 - Jun 20Cheltenham_Blue

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:20 - Jun 20 by Churchman

He’s got an exotic foreign name so he has to be good. I mean, anyone called Carlos can do no wrong. Just think Carlos Alberto, Roberto Carlos, Carlos Santana, Alcatraz the tennis dude.

Nailed on success. What on earth are they thinking employing a Gary?


Carlos The Jackal?

Poll: If we were to spend £200m would you rather

2
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:29 - Jun 20andyblue231

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:20 - Jun 20 by Churchman

He’s got an exotic foreign name so he has to be good. I mean, anyone called Carlos can do no wrong. Just think Carlos Alberto, Roberto Carlos, Carlos Santana, Alcatraz the tennis dude.

Nailed on success. What on earth are they thinking employing a Gary?


On the contrary I think O’Neil is onto his third premier league job mainly because he’s English and called Gary. Foreign managers tend to get one chance.

It doesn’t matter how much better foreign managers prove to be over decades they’re still regarded
With suspicion as a hipster gamble.
[Post edited 20 Jun 11:31]
0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:29 - Jun 20Axeldalai_lama

Isn't this what many are saying though? Has Corberan really got a better record than others we are linked with, than GON? Never managed in the prem, only west Brom and Huddersfield and did okay, brief bad time in Greece, now doing averagely in Spain.
I wouldn't be averse to him, but he's not got anything to say he's better than GON whereas GON can at least boast prem experience and, rightly or wrongly, 'keeping teams in' the prem. And whilst Corberan has pedigree as a coach and assistant etc so does GON, with Liverpool and never been out of the prem coach wise.
Not an attack on Corberan or a defence of GON specifically, I'm unsure myself, but it's interesting to look at the absolutes as opposed to instant gut feelings.
1
Login to get fewer ads

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:41 - Jun 20TRUE_BLUE123

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:25 - Jun 20 by SuffolkPunchFC

Other than being a 'foreign' manager, rather than a young English manager, I'm not sure what people see in Corberan. IMO he's not really shown credentials for being a top league manager.


Valencia were 2nd bottom in La liga when he got that job had only won 2 games and they ended up finishing 12th that season with a pretty incredible end of season run and then they improved again this season and finished 9th, 2 points off European places and Valencia isn't the easiest club to work for he has done a good job there.

I couldn't care if he was called Carlos Corberan or Carl Smith tbh.
[Post edited 20 Jun 11:42]

Poll: Will Paul Lambert be Ipswich Town manager on the final day of this season ?

0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:41 - Jun 20Churchman

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:29 - Jun 20 by andyblue231

On the contrary I think O’Neil is onto his third premier league job mainly because he’s English and called Gary. Foreign managers tend to get one chance.

It doesn’t matter how much better foreign managers prove to be over decades they’re still regarded
With suspicion as a hipster gamble.
[Post edited 20 Jun 11:31]


Really? Postecoglou has been through two PL clubs plus Celtic. Frank and Farke a couple, Emery the same, Santo four, and that’s without thinking about it. There are six British/Irish managers in the PL. I don’t see suspicion or one chance. In fact I’d say it’s highly fashionable to employ them.
1
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:41 - Jun 20Sarge

With the names I’ve seen suggested on here in the last day or two it feels like people have forgotten we’re a premier league club. Corberan, Manning, Alex Neil, Mark Robins etc are all championship managers. If we were aiming for playoffs in the Championship with a low budget this season these are the managers you’d look at, but we’re operating now on a completely different plane. I don’t think MA’s expected choice reflects that either but here we are.
0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:51 - Jun 20andyblue231

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:41 - Jun 20 by Churchman

Really? Postecoglou has been through two PL clubs plus Celtic. Frank and Farke a couple, Emery the same, Santo four, and that’s without thinking about it. There are six British/Irish managers in the PL. I don’t see suspicion or one chance. In fact I’d say it’s highly fashionable to employ them.


These comparisons are mad.

Thomas frank has only been sacked once. He’s had one success and one failure.

Same with Farke. He had one failure. And only got a prem job because he brought the team up.

Ange was a success at Celtic and has been sacked twice and absolutely will
Not get another chance. We didn’t even consider him.

Santos was a success at wolves and a success at forest and a failure at Tottenham. If he’s sacked by West Ham I don’t think he’d get another chance.

O’Neil has been sacked twice and been given a third chance.
[Post edited 20 Jun 11:58]
0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:56 - Jun 20SuffolkPunchFC

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:41 - Jun 20 by TRUE_BLUE123

Valencia were 2nd bottom in La liga when he got that job had only won 2 games and they ended up finishing 12th that season with a pretty incredible end of season run and then they improved again this season and finished 9th, 2 points off European places and Valencia isn't the easiest club to work for he has done a good job there.

I couldn't care if he was called Carlos Corberan or Carl Smith tbh.
[Post edited 20 Jun 11:42]


In a league that isn't that strong outside of the top clubs. Valencia for example are ranked 72 in Opta, way below us, Sunderland, Leeds, etc. They are ranked close the Southampton.

Mid-La Liga isn't considered top European football. You have to get into the top 4 to find clubs ranked higher than Town!
0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:59 - Jun 20Marshalls_Mullet

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:51 - Jun 20 by andyblue231

These comparisons are mad.

Thomas frank has only been sacked once. He’s had one success and one failure.

Same with Farke. He had one failure. And only got a prem job because he brought the team up.

Ange was a success at Celtic and has been sacked twice and absolutely will
Not get another chance. We didn’t even consider him.

Santos was a success at wolves and a success at forest and a failure at Tottenham. If he’s sacked by West Ham I don’t think he’d get another chance.

O’Neil has been sacked twice and been given a third chance.
[Post edited 20 Jun 11:58]


Objectively O'Neil was a success at Bournemouth though.

They had lost 3 of 4 under Parker, and lost 9-0 before GON took over. Safety was they objective, and that was comfortably achieved. He was sacked because the owner chose to go in a different direction.

If you are going to ask for objectivity in comparisons, you need to play by the same rules.

Poll: Would Lambert have acheived better results than Cook if given the same resources

1
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 12:01 - Jun 20andyblue231

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:59 - Jun 20 by Marshalls_Mullet

Objectively O'Neil was a success at Bournemouth though.

They had lost 3 of 4 under Parker, and lost 9-0 before GON took over. Safety was they objective, and that was comfortably achieved. He was sacked because the owner chose to go in a different direction.

If you are going to ask for objectivity in comparisons, you need to play by the same rules.


I think that’s fair.

I think the trouble with GON is his jobs in the prem have consisted of success and failures so everyone can see what they want a bit.

[Post edited 20 Jun 12:07]
0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 12:04 - Jun 20TRUE_BLUE123

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:56 - Jun 20 by SuffolkPunchFC

In a league that isn't that strong outside of the top clubs. Valencia for example are ranked 72 in Opta, way below us, Sunderland, Leeds, etc. They are ranked close the Southampton.

Mid-La Liga isn't considered top European football. You have to get into the top 4 to find clubs ranked higher than Town!


That’s true but on that logic Iraola would never have been given a chance at Bournemouth after his time at Vallecano. That’s not to compare Corberan and ONeil because I’m fine with the appointment of GON but I think if Corberan was given the job he would have earnt that chance as well based on his 18 months at Valencia.

Poll: Will Paul Lambert be Ipswich Town manager on the final day of this season ?

0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 12:47 - Jun 20SuffolkPunchFC

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 12:04 - Jun 20 by TRUE_BLUE123

That’s true but on that logic Iraola would never have been given a chance at Bournemouth after his time at Vallecano. That’s not to compare Corberan and ONeil because I’m fine with the appointment of GON but I think if Corberan was given the job he would have earnt that chance as well based on his 18 months at Valencia.


Don't get me wrong, I agree that Corberan is worth a punt by someone - but I think it would be exactly that, and I don't understand why anyone would place him ahead of O'Neil for where we'll find ourselves next season (looking for first season survival).

Iraola is an interesting call out, since O'Neil achieved that first season survival for Bournemouth before Iraola was brought in to further establish them in the PL. I suspect we have a similar gameplan in place - next season is just about staying in the PL, and we're looking for PL experience to help with that.
1
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 13:10 - Jun 20benrhyddingblue

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 12:01 - Jun 20 by andyblue231

I think that’s fair.

I think the trouble with GON is his jobs in the prem have consisted of success and failures so everyone can see what they want a bit.

[Post edited 20 Jun 12:07]


No it isn’t. GON kept newly promoted Bournemouth in the Premier League. He was replaced because the owner decided to move on, not because he had done a bad job. At the time many pundits said he was hard done by. He then got the job at Wolves off the back of that. Just out of interest would you take a manager whose Premier League win percentage is 10.5%, compared to one with 30%? We all would as that’s McKenna. But would many other clubs?
0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 13:11 - Jun 20TRUE_BLUE123

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 12:47 - Jun 20 by SuffolkPunchFC

Don't get me wrong, I agree that Corberan is worth a punt by someone - but I think it would be exactly that, and I don't understand why anyone would place him ahead of O'Neil for where we'll find ourselves next season (looking for first season survival).

Iraola is an interesting call out, since O'Neil achieved that first season survival for Bournemouth before Iraola was brought in to further establish them in the PL. I suspect we have a similar gameplan in place - next season is just about staying in the PL, and we're looking for PL experience to help with that.


GON losing his last 4 games that season probably did for him, Wonder how Bournemouth would have acted if he won say 2 of those.

Poll: Will Paul Lambert be Ipswich Town manager on the final day of this season ?

0
John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 13:20 - Jun 20TractorJack

John Percy in Telegraph saying Corberan was one under consideration on 11:13 - Jun 20 by Marshalls_Mullet

Why do people rate Corberan so highly? Very average record.


He massively overachieved given the situation at West Brom.
1
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2026