Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Had a debate with a mate today. 19:19 - Aug 18 with 1945 viewsMK1

He said how can it be called the English Football League when there are Welsh sides in there?
I had to agree. Whilst Cardiff, Swansea and now Wrexham are far bigger than the other sides in the Welsh League, so are Rangers and Celtic in the Scottish Premier League.

He then said that Rangers and Celtic would be Championship at best in the EFL.
Again, I agreed, as it stands today. The big difference with Celtic and Rangers is their fan base and size of grounds. If Celtic and Rangers could survive 1 season in the English Premier League, then I think they would both become stable established English Premier League clubs.

The only reason I am posting this is because I hear so many say that neither Celtic or Rangers would survive in the EPL.


Poll: New hobby suggestions for NeedhamChris.

-1
Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:25 - Aug 18Metal_Hacker

Bothered if they’d survive or not , I really wouldn’t want them in our leagues or anywhere near them

Poll: Which No.9 Would YOU Buy / Loan ?

1
Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:25 - Aug 18GlasgowBlue

Rangers are owned by the 49ers Enterprises. You could start them in the National League and they would be in the Premier League within 5 years with the sort of financial backing they have.

Antisemites, Jew haters and crashing bores will be put on ignore.
Blog: [Blog] For the Sake of My Football Club, Please Go

0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:26 - Aug 18Swansea_Blue

Very simple. It wasn’t the English Football League then, just the football league. It was expanded by incorporating a whole southern divisional league and that automatically brought in the Welsh teams you mention. There wasn’t a Welsh league back then. I’ve no idea about Scottish teams though - either they were never invited in, were invited and said no and/or they already had a national league structure.

Poll: Escaped Goat of the day. Who’s it going to be?

0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:30 - Aug 18BlueandTruesince82

Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:25 - Aug 18 by GlasgowBlue

Rangers are owned by the 49ers Enterprises. You could start them in the National League and they would be in the Premier League within 5 years with the sort of financial backing they have.


They would but wouldn't they at some point have to make a decision between them and Leeds.

I think if they got into the EFL both would make it to the PL and survive (though looking at Rangers decision making recently maybe not!). It would represent the death of Scottish lesgue football though.

Hope it never happens?

Poll: Where will Town finish the season?

-1
Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:48 - Aug 18J2BLUE

Because it is a competition run by the English FA.

What people miss about the Old Firm is that they would inject serious money into their squads with Prem income. If they knew they were part of the English game permanently I suspect they would do some sort of creative financing deal with investors to allow them to spend £500m+ in their first summer window.

I am not against them coming into the English game IF they expand the Prem to 22 teams and they both start from the very bottom tier. No entering B teams and remaining in Scotland until they are ready etc.

4 extra games a season would be massive money spinners for all involved and the extra games could be fit in by having the league cup just for the football league. Winner gets a guaranteed spot in play off semis. It could create some brilliant stories.

Imagine a team getting relegated in 22nd place but winning the cup. They would then need to win the play offs to not only avoid relegation but go up. A team like Sheff Wed fluke their way to the final of the play offs after being relegated...only to find they are facing Sheff U. Sheff U could not only seal promotion but relegate Wed. Wed could not only stay up but steal their rivals promotion spot.

The team in 21st would be waiting to see if they are sent down. Guarantee over 10 years that it would create some bat sh1t drama.
1
Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:49 - Aug 18MK1

Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:26 - Aug 18 by Swansea_Blue

Very simple. It wasn’t the English Football League then, just the football league. It was expanded by incorporating a whole southern divisional league and that automatically brought in the Welsh teams you mention. There wasn’t a Welsh league back then. I’ve no idea about Scottish teams though - either they were never invited in, were invited and said no and/or they already had a national league structure.


There has been a Welsh football league since 1902.

Poll: New hobby suggestions for NeedhamChris.

0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:50 - Aug 18BelsteadCav

I recently saw a “ top 100” league listing by opta

The Championship was ranked 10th, The Scottish premier league was ranked 42nd

I know Celtic and Rangers are well supported, but it’s a terrible standard of football.

King of the board since 98
Poll: Which way do you swing?

2
Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:53 - Aug 18MK1

Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:50 - Aug 18 by BelsteadCav

I recently saw a “ top 100” league listing by opta

The Championship was ranked 10th, The Scottish premier league was ranked 42nd

I know Celtic and Rangers are well supported, but it’s a terrible standard of football.


Yes it is, but given their fan base, they would soon establish themselves.

Poll: New hobby suggestions for NeedhamChris.

0
Login to get fewer ads

Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:55 - Aug 18armchaircritic59

May I be permitted to add this to the discussion? Taken from today's latest Opta Stats of their entire database of 13,500 world wide fully professional football clubs.

Hull City 49th ( lowest ranked PL club )
Celtic 117th
Rangers 290th
Oh, just for interest, ITFC 41st.

Make of it what you will.
0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:05 - Aug 18brazil1982

Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:53 - Aug 18 by MK1

Yes it is, but given their fan base, they would soon establish themselves.


Given their fan base? What does that mean?
0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:08 - Aug 18MK1

Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:55 - Aug 18 by armchaircritic59

May I be permitted to add this to the discussion? Taken from today's latest Opta Stats of their entire database of 13,500 world wide fully professional football clubs.

Hull City 49th ( lowest ranked PL club )
Celtic 117th
Rangers 290th
Oh, just for interest, ITFC 41st.

Make of it what you will.


Again, that is with SPL money. Give them EPL money and they would soon establish themselves.

Great stats though. Where were Norwich?

Poll: New hobby suggestions for NeedhamChris.

0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:08 - Aug 18DJR

The different treatment of Welsh and Scottish clubs probably reflects the fact that England and Wales for many purposes (including the legal system) were treated as one entity, and Scotland was treated as a separate entity.

In turn, this reflects the fact that historically Scotland was once a separate country, whereas Wales has never been a country in its own right.
[Post edited 18 Aug 20:11]
0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:09 - Aug 18MK1

Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:05 - Aug 18 by brazil1982

Given their fan base? What does that mean?


They both draw over 50,000 every home game.

Poll: New hobby suggestions for NeedhamChris.

0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:12 - Aug 18MK1

Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:08 - Aug 18 by DJR

The different treatment of Welsh and Scottish clubs probably reflects the fact that England and Wales for many purposes (including the legal system) were treated as one entity, and Scotland was treated as a separate entity.

In turn, this reflects the fact that historically Scotland was once a separate country, whereas Wales has never been a country in its own right.
[Post edited 18 Aug 20:11]


It has it's own football league though.

Poll: New hobby suggestions for NeedhamChris.

0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:42 - Aug 18DJR

Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:12 - Aug 18 by MK1

It has it's own football league though.


From Wikipedia

"The league was formed in October 1991 by Alun Evans, Secretary General of the Football Association of Wales (FAW), as he believed that the Welsh international football team was under threat from FIFA.

On its formation the league consisted of a number of teams previously playing in regional leagues across Wales, plus a small number of clubs that had been playing in the English league system."
0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:45 - Aug 18football

Personally I dont think they should be in our league
0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 21:11 - Aug 18StNeotsBlue

Had a debate with a mate today. on 19:50 - Aug 18 by BelsteadCav

I recently saw a “ top 100” league listing by opta

The Championship was ranked 10th, The Scottish premier league was ranked 42nd

I know Celtic and Rangers are well supported, but it’s a terrible standard of football.


It isn't great but I find it quite an entertaining watch, challenges that wouldn't be allowed in even the English lower leagues are often permitted, which I don't mind.

Rangers and Celtic would be top 6 in the Prem within a couple of years if they ever joined the Prem, investors would be falling over themselves to throw dough their way due to their potential.
1
Had a debate with a mate today. on 22:15 - Aug 18Vaughan8

I think you're getting 2 things mixed up. They wouldn't survive in their current state. If they were in the PL, and had the money, they'd most likely survive.

In this day an age where we have phones in our hands and google on them, you could look up why the Welsh clubs are in. They're in because there wasn't a professional league in Wales at the time of them joining the English league

I believe the "English" welsh teams used to try and qualify for Europe via the Welsh Cup but that was stopped at some point.
1
Had a debate with a mate today. on 23:09 - Aug 18BluedanW

I used to follow Berwick Rangers in the scottish league, as the only team from England. However they have slipped out of the top 4 leagues now.
Great terrace song from the 90s, 'I want to be a Berwick Ranger, only live for sex and danger'
0
Had a debate with a mate today. on 00:05 - Aug 19armchaircritic59

Had a debate with a mate today. on 20:08 - Aug 18 by MK1

Again, that is with SPL money. Give them EPL money and they would soon establish themselves.

Great stats though. Where were Norwich?


To answer your question, Norwich are currently 203rd. Rankings can change on a daily basis Monday to Friday.
0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2026