| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 09:35 - Nov 1 | dingus | I'd imagine the number of tickets going to 30+ will increase throughout the season as more people earn points. By the end of the season I'd imagine it won't be far off 100% |  | |  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 09:41 - Nov 1 | tommcd |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 09:35 - Nov 1 by dingus | I'd imagine the number of tickets going to 30+ will increase throughout the season as more people earn points. By the end of the season I'd imagine it won't be far off 100% |
Agree, which will have interesting consequences to the points-bands entering the 25/26 Season. Likely the 25/26 Season will start with around 3000 on 25+ points, a huge number on 10-14, and virtually no one on 15-24. |  |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 10:35 - Nov 1 | Chris_ITFC | You can now clearly see the “closed shop” effect emerging. Last 3 games: - 30+ getting bigger and bigger - 25+ and 20+ getting smaller and smaller - 15+ approaching zero chance to get any 30+ will keep expanding, 15+ will soon have 0 chance, and that will soon spread to anyone left at 20+. Thanks for your work Tom. I hope the Club consider this analysis at the end of the season, or presumably every 3000 allocation will become limited to a group of fans* not much bigger than that. *Deserving they sure are, but not really a desirable system all things considered. |  |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 10:57 - Nov 1 | tractorshark |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 10:35 - Nov 1 by Chris_ITFC | You can now clearly see the “closed shop” effect emerging. Last 3 games: - 30+ getting bigger and bigger - 25+ and 20+ getting smaller and smaller - 15+ approaching zero chance to get any 30+ will keep expanding, 15+ will soon have 0 chance, and that will soon spread to anyone left at 20+. Thanks for your work Tom. I hope the Club consider this analysis at the end of the season, or presumably every 3000 allocation will become limited to a group of fans* not much bigger than that. *Deserving they sure are, but not really a desirable system all things considered. |
Yes it’s going to become a closed shop but it’s the same at every Premier League club. I’m not sure how you make it fairer without penalising those who have spent buckets going up and down the country. Most people who complain about the system will have their own agendas, which undoubtedly will increase their chances of getting a ticket. But the harsh reality of the situation is if those people had gone to six away games last season (tickets were readily available to do that) and then continued this season, they wouldn’t be complaining now. My only gripe is I see a lot of people who have jumped on the bandwagon in the last two seasons and that has come at the expense of exiled fans who have been loyal for decades, including my eldest son. But that falls into the bracket of agendas and the same applies to my son as it does to others. In my humble opinion, the club have got it right with away games. They can’t go back years and years to find someone who went to Stockport away. Where would the cutoff point be? Bottom line is they have to reward recent loyalty and that encourages people to keep attending. If they don’t, there are plenty of people who will replace them. And there is still the option of home games. By making the attendance stipulation just one game last season, that has very much opened the door to the casual fan. [Post edited 1 Nov 2024 10:58]
|  | |  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:04 - Nov 1 | Reuser_is_God |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 09:41 - Nov 1 by tommcd | Agree, which will have interesting consequences to the points-bands entering the 25/26 Season. Likely the 25/26 Season will start with around 3000 on 25+ points, a huge number on 10-14, and virtually no one on 15-24. |
Maybe there will be a complete reset of points in the summer? |  |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:05 - Nov 1 | JakeITFC |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 10:57 - Nov 1 by tractorshark | Yes it’s going to become a closed shop but it’s the same at every Premier League club. I’m not sure how you make it fairer without penalising those who have spent buckets going up and down the country. Most people who complain about the system will have their own agendas, which undoubtedly will increase their chances of getting a ticket. But the harsh reality of the situation is if those people had gone to six away games last season (tickets were readily available to do that) and then continued this season, they wouldn’t be complaining now. My only gripe is I see a lot of people who have jumped on the bandwagon in the last two seasons and that has come at the expense of exiled fans who have been loyal for decades, including my eldest son. But that falls into the bracket of agendas and the same applies to my son as it does to others. In my humble opinion, the club have got it right with away games. They can’t go back years and years to find someone who went to Stockport away. Where would the cutoff point be? Bottom line is they have to reward recent loyalty and that encourages people to keep attending. If they don’t, there are plenty of people who will replace them. And there is still the option of home games. By making the attendance stipulation just one game last season, that has very much opened the door to the casual fan. [Post edited 1 Nov 2024 10:58]
|
All very true, and I think the key part is that in both the league one and championship promotion seasons, a person starting from a low base could still have got up to a reasonable amount for this year and so loyalty has been rewarded in that sense. I do miss the days of picking and choosing, being able to bring along friends who don’t want to do every week etc. but I guess that’s the price of success. I think my one change would be to increase the ballot percentage to maybe 5% or even 10%. |  | |  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:06 - Nov 1 | ITFC_Forever |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 10:57 - Nov 1 by tractorshark | Yes it’s going to become a closed shop but it’s the same at every Premier League club. I’m not sure how you make it fairer without penalising those who have spent buckets going up and down the country. Most people who complain about the system will have their own agendas, which undoubtedly will increase their chances of getting a ticket. But the harsh reality of the situation is if those people had gone to six away games last season (tickets were readily available to do that) and then continued this season, they wouldn’t be complaining now. My only gripe is I see a lot of people who have jumped on the bandwagon in the last two seasons and that has come at the expense of exiled fans who have been loyal for decades, including my eldest son. But that falls into the bracket of agendas and the same applies to my son as it does to others. In my humble opinion, the club have got it right with away games. They can’t go back years and years to find someone who went to Stockport away. Where would the cutoff point be? Bottom line is they have to reward recent loyalty and that encourages people to keep attending. If they don’t, there are plenty of people who will replace them. And there is still the option of home games. By making the attendance stipulation just one game last season, that has very much opened the door to the casual fan. [Post edited 1 Nov 2024 10:58]
|
While demand exceeds supply, there will always be some who are unhappy - it is mathematically impossible to please everyone. Therefore, choices have to be made - and the one the club have made is the correct one. And as many have said, you really didn't need to go to many away games last season to be ok for this season. |  |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:12 - Nov 1 | Kievthegreat |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 10:35 - Nov 1 by Chris_ITFC | You can now clearly see the “closed shop” effect emerging. Last 3 games: - 30+ getting bigger and bigger - 25+ and 20+ getting smaller and smaller - 15+ approaching zero chance to get any 30+ will keep expanding, 15+ will soon have 0 chance, and that will soon spread to anyone left at 20+. Thanks for your work Tom. I hope the Club consider this analysis at the end of the season, or presumably every 3000 allocation will become limited to a group of fans* not much bigger than that. *Deserving they sure are, but not really a desirable system all things considered. |
It wouldn't surprise me if they looked at some sort of wider distribution of tickets. I think there could be fairer systems. Example with arbitrary numbers based very roughly on Southampton: Window 1: 25% available for 30+ points Window 2: An extra 25% available for 25+ points Window 3: An extra 20% available for 20+ point Window 4: An extra 20% available for 15+ point Window 5: 10% ballot for 10 points and up (i.e 2 years membership lets you into a ballot) Being in 30+ window is still hugely rewarded with a big chunk, plus you can participate in all windows to increase your opportunities. However while 15+ is still a slog (as you'll have all the people above taking part in your window), it is one where luck could see you progress. I also think giving a way in for new away followers (via 2 years membership) would allow new and younger fans to join long term. I'm sure you'd have to tweak numbers to strike the right balance, especially for smaller allocations. To me a system that massively rewards loyalty, but that let's those on the cusp not get locked out would be better. PS. I only ever went to the odd away match and didn't have a membership last year, so doesn't effect/benefit me in the slightest. Just my attempted impartial opinion to what I perceive to be flaw in the system, that long term new fans will be locked out. |  | |  | Login to get fewer ads
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:14 - Nov 1 | Fixed_It |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:04 - Nov 1 by Reuser_is_God | Maybe there will be a complete reset of points in the summer? |
Imagine the carnage on the website for the first away game?! |  |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:16 - Nov 1 | ITFC_Forever |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:04 - Nov 1 by Reuser_is_God | Maybe there will be a complete reset of points in the summer? |
No chance. |  |
|  |
| Yep, and there’s no getting away from it…. on 11:19 - Nov 1 | Bloots |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:06 - Nov 1 by ITFC_Forever | While demand exceeds supply, there will always be some who are unhappy - it is mathematically impossible to please everyone. Therefore, choices have to be made - and the one the club have made is the correct one. And as many have said, you really didn't need to go to many away games last season to be ok for this season. |
….I don’t like using the word but it’s really just “gloryhunting”. If you had a membership and went to 10 aways last year you’d have been fine this season. Ultimately the people moaning are those that didn’t get off their arses and go to matches at the beginning of last season when we didn’t think we’d have a chance of promotion. Meh. |  |
| Serial upvoter and TWTD Legend. |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:19 - Nov 1 | Chris_ITFC |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 10:57 - Nov 1 by tractorshark | Yes it’s going to become a closed shop but it’s the same at every Premier League club. I’m not sure how you make it fairer without penalising those who have spent buckets going up and down the country. Most people who complain about the system will have their own agendas, which undoubtedly will increase their chances of getting a ticket. But the harsh reality of the situation is if those people had gone to six away games last season (tickets were readily available to do that) and then continued this season, they wouldn’t be complaining now. My only gripe is I see a lot of people who have jumped on the bandwagon in the last two seasons and that has come at the expense of exiled fans who have been loyal for decades, including my eldest son. But that falls into the bracket of agendas and the same applies to my son as it does to others. In my humble opinion, the club have got it right with away games. They can’t go back years and years to find someone who went to Stockport away. Where would the cutoff point be? Bottom line is they have to reward recent loyalty and that encourages people to keep attending. If they don’t, there are plenty of people who will replace them. And there is still the option of home games. By making the attendance stipulation just one game last season, that has very much opened the door to the casual fan. [Post edited 1 Nov 2024 10:58]
|
Yes, I don’t disagree with a lot of that. I just think it’s the ballot that needs tweaking. Sure, those people are deserving and don’t deserve to be penalised. In some cases, I dare say they are being forced to go more often/ spend more than they would ideally like just to retain the ability to go at all, so fair play to them for that. However, I do think if the ballot was increased slightly, that would still allow the loyal away masses to regularly access tickets, but would bring the added benefit of giving many thousands of other fans a genuine chance of getting an away ticket or two across the course of a whole season. At the moment, 2% basically creates a situation where the top 4000 odd people have ~3000 tickets every week and every other Town fan has to be lucky enough to get 1 of ~1200 tickets across the whole season (2% of 3000 * 20). I think that balance could alter slightly, without me being too inward-looking about it. |  |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:27 - Nov 1 | Kievthegreat |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:04 - Nov 1 by Reuser_is_God | Maybe there will be a complete reset of points in the summer? |
Think this could be slightly too far in the opposite direction? |  | |  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:35 - Nov 1 | Chris_ITFC |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:27 - Nov 1 by Kievthegreat | Think this could be slightly too far in the opposite direction? |
Civil war. Last season’s will drop off though. |  |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:36 - Nov 1 | tractorboy1978 |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:05 - Nov 1 by JakeITFC | All very true, and I think the key part is that in both the league one and championship promotion seasons, a person starting from a low base could still have got up to a reasonable amount for this year and so loyalty has been rewarded in that sense. I do miss the days of picking and choosing, being able to bring along friends who don’t want to do every week etc. but I guess that’s the price of success. I think my one change would be to increase the ballot percentage to maybe 5% or even 10%. |
"I do miss the days of picking and choosing, being able to bring along friends who don’t want to do every week" - to be honest, I think that still happens to a degree. I think lots of people have 'borrowed' a number off a mate for a one off game. Unless you start spot checking significant numbers of people, you aren't going to really stop that. |  | |  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:38 - Nov 1 | Guthrum |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 11:04 - Nov 1 by Reuser_is_God | Maybe there will be a complete reset of points in the summer? |
Possibly that points from a couple of seasons ago will "expire". |  |
|  |
| Yep, and there’s no getting away from it…. on 12:09 - Nov 1 | VanDusen |
| Yep, and there’s no getting away from it…. on 11:19 - Nov 1 by Bloots | ….I don’t like using the word but it’s really just “gloryhunting”. If you had a membership and went to 10 aways last year you’d have been fine this season. Ultimately the people moaning are those that didn’t get off their arses and go to matches at the beginning of last season when we didn’t think we’d have a chance of promotion. Meh. |
Precisely. There has been 22 years of opportunity to get away tickets pretty easily for almost any game you chose, bar Norwich and the odd play-off or small ground (Wimbledon 2020 or Bracknell 2022). Those moaning their membership's got them nothing this year should consider the hardcore who have spent £30-40 on a gold card each of those seasons largely for nothing - (especially given in the end these high demand games were allocated directly via invitation to purchase letters). And the reason we have this system now rather than a complete reset is the free for all at Cambridge two years ago where loyal fans DID miss out (itself caused by a reduced allocation due to the d*ckheads who caused trouble in the standing area next to the Cambs fans the previous season meaning we didn't get the several hundred there). If anything the whole scheme should have been tweaked initially to cover 2-3 seasons history which would have provided a higher bar for entry in the first place and reduced this happening so soon. Odd 'glory hunting' though. Brentford last week was about as deflating an away experience as I've had in years - even worse than Charlton two years ago, where at least you had the consolation of having seen a 'once in a lifetime' crazy occurrence... ;o) Mind you - way it's going we may well be back to substantial allocations at Blackburn and Preston next season anyway... |  | |  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 12:14 - Nov 1 | brazil1982 |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 09:41 - Nov 1 by tommcd | Agree, which will have interesting consequences to the points-bands entering the 25/26 Season. Likely the 25/26 Season will start with around 3000 on 25+ points, a huge number on 10-14, and virtually no one on 15-24. |
I think the consequence is a good number not renewing memberships next year. I won't. |  | |  |
| Yep, and there’s no getting away from it…. on 12:18 - Nov 1 | ParisBlue |
| Yep, and there’s no getting away from it…. on 12:09 - Nov 1 by VanDusen | Precisely. There has been 22 years of opportunity to get away tickets pretty easily for almost any game you chose, bar Norwich and the odd play-off or small ground (Wimbledon 2020 or Bracknell 2022). Those moaning their membership's got them nothing this year should consider the hardcore who have spent £30-40 on a gold card each of those seasons largely for nothing - (especially given in the end these high demand games were allocated directly via invitation to purchase letters). And the reason we have this system now rather than a complete reset is the free for all at Cambridge two years ago where loyal fans DID miss out (itself caused by a reduced allocation due to the d*ckheads who caused trouble in the standing area next to the Cambs fans the previous season meaning we didn't get the several hundred there). If anything the whole scheme should have been tweaked initially to cover 2-3 seasons history which would have provided a higher bar for entry in the first place and reduced this happening so soon. Odd 'glory hunting' though. Brentford last week was about as deflating an away experience as I've had in years - even worse than Charlton two years ago, where at least you had the consolation of having seen a 'once in a lifetime' crazy occurrence... ;o) Mind you - way it's going we may well be back to substantial allocations at Blackburn and Preston next season anyway... |
Neither Blackburn or Preston sold out last season. |  |
|  |
| Yep, and there’s no getting away from it…. on 12:22 - Nov 1 | VanDusen |
| Yep, and there’s no getting away from it…. on 12:18 - Nov 1 by ParisBlue | Neither Blackburn or Preston sold out last season. |
Exactly - as many tickets as you want! We'll then see what the latent demand really is for aways... ;o) |  | |  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 12:23 - Nov 1 | tractorshark | Playing Devil’s advocate but the acid test will come if we’re relegated. Away tickets would be readily available again so I presume those who have complained about the system would leap at the opportunity and start going to the likes of Swansea, Coventry, Preston etc. Or is it just they fancy a trip to Manchester United? |  | |  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 14:15 - Nov 1 | C_HealyIsAPleasure |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 10:35 - Nov 1 by Chris_ITFC | You can now clearly see the “closed shop” effect emerging. Last 3 games: - 30+ getting bigger and bigger - 25+ and 20+ getting smaller and smaller - 15+ approaching zero chance to get any 30+ will keep expanding, 15+ will soon have 0 chance, and that will soon spread to anyone left at 20+. Thanks for your work Tom. I hope the Club consider this analysis at the end of the season, or presumably every 3000 allocation will become limited to a group of fans* not much bigger than that. *Deserving they sure are, but not really a desirable system all things considered. |
Personally think the most interesting thing here is that the drop in 25+ and 20+ is larger than the growth in 30+ (or to put it more simply, more tickets for this game have reached 15+), which indicates some of those in higher priority have chosen not to go to this one Might be as simple as being a less attractive game compared to Spurs (particularly as we’ve had many a trip to the City Ground in the last decade), but potentially also a sign that for a few the novelty is starting to wear off Will be interesting to see if that continues, especially if results don’t improve, and more tickets continue to fall to the 15+ bracket (arguably if that happens we may then start to see some fall right through to 10+) |  |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 14:36 - Nov 1 | Steve_M |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 14:15 - Nov 1 by C_HealyIsAPleasure | Personally think the most interesting thing here is that the drop in 25+ and 20+ is larger than the growth in 30+ (or to put it more simply, more tickets for this game have reached 15+), which indicates some of those in higher priority have chosen not to go to this one Might be as simple as being a less attractive game compared to Spurs (particularly as we’ve had many a trip to the City Ground in the last decade), but potentially also a sign that for a few the novelty is starting to wear off Will be interesting to see if that continues, especially if results don’t improve, and more tickets continue to fall to the 15+ bracket (arguably if that happens we may then start to see some fall right through to 10+) |
I wonder if there's a also an element of people choosing Forest or Wolves here too, think that looked like the case with Brighton and Southampton too. It's particularly unfortunate for those who've not been able to get away tickets that so many of our fixtures are relatively close to Ipswich with only Man City away being a longer trip. That just compounds the demand. |  |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 17:23 - Nov 1 | LankHenners |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 10:57 - Nov 1 by tractorshark | Yes it’s going to become a closed shop but it’s the same at every Premier League club. I’m not sure how you make it fairer without penalising those who have spent buckets going up and down the country. Most people who complain about the system will have their own agendas, which undoubtedly will increase their chances of getting a ticket. But the harsh reality of the situation is if those people had gone to six away games last season (tickets were readily available to do that) and then continued this season, they wouldn’t be complaining now. My only gripe is I see a lot of people who have jumped on the bandwagon in the last two seasons and that has come at the expense of exiled fans who have been loyal for decades, including my eldest son. But that falls into the bracket of agendas and the same applies to my son as it does to others. In my humble opinion, the club have got it right with away games. They can’t go back years and years to find someone who went to Stockport away. Where would the cutoff point be? Bottom line is they have to reward recent loyalty and that encourages people to keep attending. If they don’t, there are plenty of people who will replace them. And there is still the option of home games. By making the attendance stipulation just one game last season, that has very much opened the door to the casual fan. [Post edited 1 Nov 2024 10:58]
|
Think there are only a couple of things you could quibble about with the club's process on tickets - one is not going back x amount of seasons to weed out the 'gloryhunters' you mention but as you say hard to draw the line on that. The other is for home games where the ballot is open to anyone who went to 1 game with a membership so people who put the money and effort in all season potentially lose out on tickets to someone who jumped in for a couple of games towards the end of the season when it got particularly exciting. Helps the casuals out like you say (good, imo) but seems a bit at odds with their strategy for away games. Seem to have this conversation every week but demand will always outstrip supply as long as we're doing well and think the club have got it right on the whole. As an aside, wonder what the general opinion would be among fans of all clubs if the maximum away ticket price was raised but clubs were forced to adhere to the 10% rule if they could go over 3000 seats for away fans. Hidden drawback of the cap is the big clubs who could easily host at least double the away fans they do refusing to do so because they can sell a ticket to a home supporter for more than they can an away one. |  |
|  |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 17:55 - Nov 1 | VanDusen |
| Nottingham Forest Ticket Sales 'Profile' on 17:23 - Nov 1 by LankHenners | Think there are only a couple of things you could quibble about with the club's process on tickets - one is not going back x amount of seasons to weed out the 'gloryhunters' you mention but as you say hard to draw the line on that. The other is for home games where the ballot is open to anyone who went to 1 game with a membership so people who put the money and effort in all season potentially lose out on tickets to someone who jumped in for a couple of games towards the end of the season when it got particularly exciting. Helps the casuals out like you say (good, imo) but seems a bit at odds with their strategy for away games. Seem to have this conversation every week but demand will always outstrip supply as long as we're doing well and think the club have got it right on the whole. As an aside, wonder what the general opinion would be among fans of all clubs if the maximum away ticket price was raised but clubs were forced to adhere to the 10% rule if they could go over 3000 seats for away fans. Hidden drawback of the cap is the big clubs who could easily host at least double the away fans they do refusing to do so because they can sell a ticket to a home supporter for more than they can an away one. |
Re. that idea on the cap. So sort of like UEFA do at tournaments with the 'fan first' tickets for England (and presumably all other participating countries) which are dramatically cheaper? And which the FA allocate precisely on that basis in a staggered release so that the fans with the most caps (same as our priority points) are guaranteed to get one. The fan first ticket for the final in 2021 was just £90 whereas the next level up was £300 and the highest tier £600 or something. It was similar for Berlin this summer too. It's an interesting idea, although I suspect most clubs in this corrupt showbiz league would prefer to sell to nominal 'home' fans from all around the world rather than away supporters... [Post edited 1 Nov 2024 17:55]
|  | |  |
| |