| Important not to overreact 12:50 - Dec 22 with 7360 views | itfcjoe | Bad day at the office, but it’s the first game for 2-3 months which we’ve just not been in from start to finish and that will happen. Missed Delap big time, with no out ball we had to keep playing out and they could cheat and press the life out of us. Absolute masterclass from Tonali and Bruno, as good as I’ve seen this season. Too many players had an off day, from the first second of the game - Burgess, Morsy and Chaplin right through the spine didn’t have good games, lost nearly all their one v ones and can’t do that in the PL. Tough couple of games coming up, need to get some players back fit and a couple of fresh additions - we only need to finish 1 spot higher than we currently are |  |
| |  |
| Important not to overreact on 12:53 - Dec 22 | bournemouthblue | When you look at Newcastle and break them down, you can see why they have had Champions League football They have started the season slowly but are well capable of kicking on and giving far better sides than us a bloody nose They're not the sort of side we are likely to be competing with at this stage There's no shame in losing to them, we could have made things more difficult for them but I'm not sure it's in McKenna's DNA to try and play that way, which might be his undoing a little bit He has to be adaptive at times |  |
|  |
| Important not to overreact on 12:56 - Dec 22 | tonybied | Tonali is a beast and I expect he will play for a top club sooner or later. He was pretty much unplayable yesterday. |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 12:57 - Dec 22 | backwaywhen | Spot on Joe , I don’t think Palace will over react after getting thumped by Arsenal yesterday , these results happen throughout the season to most clubs , not nice but try to learn from it . |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 12:58 - Dec 22 | reusersfreekicks |
| Important not to overreact on 12:53 - Dec 22 by bournemouthblue | When you look at Newcastle and break them down, you can see why they have had Champions League football They have started the season slowly but are well capable of kicking on and giving far better sides than us a bloody nose They're not the sort of side we are likely to be competing with at this stage There's no shame in losing to them, we could have made things more difficult for them but I'm not sure it's in McKenna's DNA to try and play that way, which might be his undoing a little bit He has to be adaptive at times |
I agree a bit more pragmatism to stop other sides playing is needed.Newcastle had so much space even in out box |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 13:20 - Dec 22 | Illinoisblue | A very bad day at the office and there’s a nagging feeling that yesterday marked the beginning of the end, such was the awfulness of our display. BUT, a lot of football to be played and players to return from injury. We’re not dead yet |  |
|  |
| Important not to overreact on 13:22 - Dec 22 | pointofblue | I'd argue Palace was very similar regarding not being on it from start to finish and that was only three weeks a go, give or take. They just didn't have the number of attacking players to take advantage of it. |  |
|  |
| Important not to overreact on 16:35 - Dec 22 | itfcjoe |
| Important not to overreact on 13:22 - Dec 22 by pointofblue | I'd argue Palace was very similar regarding not being on it from start to finish and that was only three weeks a go, give or take. They just didn't have the number of attacking players to take advantage of it. |
We hit the post late on which would have equalised so clearly were still in the game |  |
|  | Login to get fewer ads
| Important not to overreact on 17:05 - Dec 22 | DJR | We obviously have to keep the faith, and hopefully we will strengthen in January, but the thing that worries me is that very few of our remaining fixtures are anything but fairly or very difficult, given the level that the vast majority of Premier League teams appear to be at. Indeed, of our next 6 fixtures, the "easiest" appears to be Brighton at home. Sadly, it doesn't necessarily get much easier after that. The real shame for my part is that we really ought to have got a further five or six points in recent weeks which would have made our task from now on that bit easier, assuming that, say, 34 points is needed to avoid relegation. |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:08 - Dec 22 | FrimleyBlue | Correct.. but please can there at least be acknowledgement that we do need to say thank you but goodbye to 60/70% of our squad to move forwards. ( for clarity.. From those who got us promoted. ) [Post edited 22 Dec 2024 21:08]
|  |
|  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:16 - Dec 22 | NedPlimpton |
| Important not to overreact on 17:08 - Dec 22 by FrimleyBlue | Correct.. but please can there at least be acknowledgement that we do need to say thank you but goodbye to 60/70% of our squad to move forwards. ( for clarity.. From those who got us promoted. ) [Post edited 22 Dec 2024 21:08]
|
OP: Important not to overreact Frimmers: Correct, but 90% of our squad need to go |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:37 - Dec 22 | reusersfreekicks |
| Important not to overreact on 17:08 - Dec 22 by FrimleyBlue | Correct.. but please can there at least be acknowledgement that we do need to say thank you but goodbye to 60/70% of our squad to move forwards. ( for clarity.. From those who got us promoted. ) [Post edited 22 Dec 2024 21:08]
|
90%!! Can we do the same with forum posters? Starting with those most responsible for hyperbole and hot takes |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:42 - Dec 22 | FrimleyBlue |
| Important not to overreact on 17:37 - Dec 22 by reusersfreekicks | 90%!! Can we do the same with forum posters? Starting with those most responsible for hyperbole and hot takes |
When you think of stable prem clubs. You must see that we need to effectively replace the majority of the past 2 season journey players.. that's close to 90% of the squad no? Other way of looking at it. If you were a prem side. Which of our league 1 promoted squad would you be looking to sign from us? Besides Davis of course. I know you like to make out I'm making hot takes. But serious conversation here. |  |
|  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:44 - Dec 22 | SuffolkPunchFC |
| Important not to overreact on 17:08 - Dec 22 by FrimleyBlue | Correct.. but please can there at least be acknowledgement that we do need to say thank you but goodbye to 60/70% of our squad to move forwards. ( for clarity.. From those who got us promoted. ) [Post edited 22 Dec 2024 21:08]
|
90% is a crazy take on the squad, but you don't say over how many seasons. Sure, we need to strengthen EVERY position, and that inevitable means many players will move on, but to suggest 24-25 players need to be waved goodbye to is (hopefully) hyperbole. [Post edited 22 Dec 2024 17:46]
|  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:44 - Dec 22 | NedPlimpton |
| Important not to overreact on 17:42 - Dec 22 by FrimleyBlue | When you think of stable prem clubs. You must see that we need to effectively replace the majority of the past 2 season journey players.. that's close to 90% of the squad no? Other way of looking at it. If you were a prem side. Which of our league 1 promoted squad would you be looking to sign from us? Besides Davis of course. I know you like to make out I'm making hot takes. But serious conversation here. |
But we're not aiming for stable premier league club this season. The aim is literally to finish 17th. And we're not that far off it |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:46 - Dec 22 | reusersfreekicks |
| Important not to overreact on 17:42 - Dec 22 by FrimleyBlue | When you think of stable prem clubs. You must see that we need to effectively replace the majority of the past 2 season journey players.. that's close to 90% of the squad no? Other way of looking at it. If you were a prem side. Which of our league 1 promoted squad would you be looking to sign from us? Besides Davis of course. I know you like to make out I'm making hot takes. But serious conversation here. |
Our league 1 players don't make up anywhere near 90% of the squad. Just an attention seeking headline imo. Squad of say 25. So 2-3 players only being kept? |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:46 - Dec 22 | FrimleyBlue |
| Important not to overreact on 17:44 - Dec 22 by NedPlimpton | But we're not aiming for stable premier league club this season. The aim is literally to finish 17th. And we're not that far off it |
Didn't say this Jan window ffs lol. |  |
|  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:47 - Dec 22 | reusersfreekicks |
| Important not to overreact on 17:44 - Dec 22 by SuffolkPunchFC | 90% is a crazy take on the squad, but you don't say over how many seasons. Sure, we need to strengthen EVERY position, and that inevitable means many players will move on, but to suggest 24-25 players need to be waved goodbye to is (hopefully) hyperbole. [Post edited 22 Dec 2024 17:46]
|
You spelt bullsh1t incorrectly |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:48 - Dec 22 | NedPlimpton |
| Important not to overreact on 17:46 - Dec 22 by FrimleyBlue | Didn't say this Jan window ffs lol. |
Sorry Frimmers, it's genuinely hard to tell with you! |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 17:50 - Dec 22 | FrimleyBlue |
| Important not to overreact on 17:46 - Dec 22 by reusersfreekicks | Our league 1 players don't make up anywhere near 90% of the squad. Just an attention seeking headline imo. Squad of say 25. So 2-3 players only being kept? |
Oh yes sorry. Forgot you have to be very specific with figures on here ffs. Sorry for not stating the specific percentage for you to be able to have a discussion. |  |
|  |
| Important not to overreact on 18:07 - Dec 22 | reusersfreekicks |
| Important not to overreact on 17:50 - Dec 22 by FrimleyBlue | Oh yes sorry. Forgot you have to be very specific with figures on here ffs. Sorry for not stating the specific percentage for you to be able to have a discussion. |
You misinterpret me. I am stating how few players would be retained if your hot take off 90% of the squad has to go. 3 is a generous calculation, 2 is being a bit harsh. Hence 2-3 |  | |  |
| Important not to overreact on 20:38 - Dec 22 | FrimleyBlue |
| Important not to overreact on 18:07 - Dec 22 by reusersfreekicks | You misinterpret me. I am stating how few players would be retained if your hot take off 90% of the squad has to go. 3 is a generous calculation, 2 is being a bit harsh. Hence 2-3 |
Obviously all about opinions but if we stay up. I can't see us going into 25/26 with any of the promotion side bar Davis and Hutch in the match day 18. |  |
|  |
| Important not to overreact on 20:50 - Dec 22 | itfcjoe |
| Important not to overreact on 17:08 - Dec 22 by FrimleyBlue | Correct.. but please can there at least be acknowledgement that we do need to say thank you but goodbye to 60/70% of our squad to move forwards. ( for clarity.. From those who got us promoted. ) [Post edited 22 Dec 2024 21:08]
|
No, because that’s nonsense |  |
|  |
| Important not to overreact on 20:54 - Dec 22 | FrimleyBlue |
| Important not to overreact on 20:50 - Dec 22 by itfcjoe | No, because that’s nonsense |
So 25/26. Who do you think will remain from the promotion winning squad. |  |
|  |
| Important not to overreact on 20:55 - Dec 22 | itfcjoe |
| Important not to overreact on 20:54 - Dec 22 by FrimleyBlue | So 25/26. Who do you think will remain from the promotion winning squad. |
What relevance does the promotion winning squad have with the current squad? |  |
|  |
| |