Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' 14:56 - Jan 9 with 7570 viewsCafe_Newman

I think more people will agree with "Ange" than those that don't. What's the feeling here at TWTD?


https://www.bbc.com/sport/foot

At the very least, I think the BBC are silly to call his comments a tirade.



(apologies if I'm late to the party and this has already been discussed)

In wartime, truth is so precious that she should always be attended by a bodyguard of lies. Winston Churchill

4
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:11 - Jan 9BseaBlue

I'd probably agree that it is changing too much. However, for him to state that things were never debated before VAR is a massive reach!
2
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:12 - Jan 9Cheltenham_Blue

He made a lot of good points.

But, I think that his comment, something to do with this, 'being the home of football, so why is a bloke from Australia the only one that seems to have a problem with it', will almost certainly have triggered certain elements of the press.

We all know how much they love a foreigner telling us what to do.

Poll: If we were to spend £200m would you rather

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:13 - Jan 9tcblue

He's the biggest whinger in the league, or maybe joint biggest with Arteta. I can't be objective as to what he's banging on about here
0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:18 - Jan 9HighgateBlue

I really dislike it when he's grumpy and refuses to answer a question properly because he's in a huff.

So I'm not going to grumble when he sets out his thoughts in a pretty considered way as he does here. I don't think it's a tirade at all, on this occasion. I do think a lot of people will have sympathy with what he says. Although I'm not sure that he, I, or anyone else has anything close to a perfect answer to the problem (especially given that we know VAR is not going anywhere).
0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:20 - Jan 9Basuco

Biggest shock is that Stuart Atwell got the rules right!
1
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:21 - Jan 9Dubtractor

Read that earlier and agreed with most of it. Especially the bit about how odd it is that people are getting excited about the ref speaking over the pa system!

I was born underwater, I dried out in the sun. I started humping volcanoes baby, when I was too young.
Poll: Win, Draw or Lose tomorrow then?

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:22 - Jan 9Guthrum

'We never used to debate offsides, we never used to debate handballs, we never used to debate holding in the box, we never used to debate so many things.' Has he ever talked to any fans, or read old interviews? Managers have been moaning about decisions going against them since time immemorial. VAR has just given them a new layer of officials to complain about when they don't get what they want.

Good Lord! Whatever is it?
Poll: McCarthy: A More Nuanced Poll
Blog: [Blog] For Those Panicking About the Lack of Transfer Activity

2
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:23 - Jan 9Illinoisblue

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:20 - Jan 9 by Basuco

Biggest shock is that Stuart Atwell got the rules right!


If I’m reading it right, Bergvall didn’t get that second yellow because the ref played the advantage and even though the advantage came to nothing, the ref can’t then go back and book the player. That seems wrong on multiple levels.

62 - 78 - 81
Poll: What sport is the most corrupt?

0
Login to get fewer ads

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:27 - Jan 9Reuser_is_God

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:21 - Jan 9 by Dubtractor

Read that earlier and agreed with most of it. Especially the bit about how odd it is that people are getting excited about the ref speaking over the pa system!


Utter woke nonsense

Evans out
Poll: Are Burgers the new Cheese?

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:29 - Jan 9GeoffSentence

I found it little tricky to decipher what he was tlking about, but I think it boiled down to 'fwck VAR'

Don't boil a kettle on a boat.
Poll: The best Williams to play for Town

1
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:31 - Jan 9Basuco

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:23 - Jan 9 by Illinoisblue

If I’m reading it right, Bergvall didn’t get that second yellow because the ref played the advantage and even though the advantage came to nothing, the ref can’t then go back and book the player. That seems wrong on multiple levels.


It's not wrong, just vague and open to interpretation, it can be applied whatever way the referee chooses and he is always correct. Like most rules in football.
0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:33 - Jan 9DanTheMan

I agree with his general point but this made me laugh...

"We never used to debate offsides, we never used to debate handbells..."

Maybe I'm misreading but people absolutely did these things and being able to debate them after the game at the pub was something people used to say VAR would ruin.

Poll: FM Parallel Game Week 1 (Fulham) - Available Team

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:47 - Jan 9Cafe_Newman

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:33 - Jan 9 by DanTheMan

I agree with his general point but this made me laugh...

"We never used to debate offsides, we never used to debate handbells..."

Maybe I'm misreading but people absolutely did these things and being able to debate them after the game at the pub was something people used to say VAR would ruin.


Imagine the fuss we would have made if Maradonna had actually handled the ball in that World Cup Semifinal in 1986.

In wartime, truth is so precious that she should always be attended by a bodyguard of lies. Winston Churchill

1
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:51 - Jan 9urbanpenguin

There might be some good points to what he's saying, but he seems a really bad communicator. I know interviews after a game aren't the best format for eloquence, but he's really, really bad at presenting a point or argument in a clear way, and instead loops and returns and repeats and does himself no favours. Compare him to McKenna and I think we are so lucky to have a manager who can communicate clearly for us as fans but especially for players

Poll: You HAVe to select one of the below to be new manager
Blog: Some People Are On the Pitch...

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:54 - Jan 9LankHenners

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:21 - Jan 9 by Dubtractor

Read that earlier and agreed with most of it. Especially the bit about how odd it is that people are getting excited about the ref speaking over the pa system!


Perfect example of how tone deaf the FA are with regards to what fans think makes the sport good. Their solution to frustration that no-one inside the ground knows exactly what's going on and what's being discussed when the VAR stuff is going on is to keep it exactly the same but have the ref speak their decision into a mic when everyone can see what the outcome is anyway by their signals.

Just because I don't care doesn't mean I don't understand.
Poll: What is Celina's problem?

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:57 - Jan 9Garv

He's right.

He asked a good question re: whether we really want to see referee's mic'd up and talking to the whole stadium to explain how offside works. The answer should be no, it's not Rugby or Cricket and it shouldn't be used as theatre - let the football be the entertainment.

Poll: By only voting with your head and not heart, will we stay up?

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 16:14 - Jan 9Scuzzer

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:57 - Jan 9 by Garv

He's right.

He asked a good question re: whether we really want to see referee's mic'd up and talking to the whole stadium to explain how offside works. The answer should be no, it's not Rugby or Cricket and it shouldn't be used as theatre - let the football be the entertainment.


Would be a waste of time down at Portman Road...cant decipher anything over that PA.

Established 1968

1
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 17:22 - Jan 9homer_123

No Ange, it's not what the people want, it never, ever, ever was.

OK, let me re-phrase. It's not what the fans wanted.

Might be wanted by those in charge of football.

Ade Akinbiyi couldn't hit a cows arse with a banjo...
Poll: Has Omari travelled?

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 20:00 - Jan 10Garv

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 16:14 - Jan 9 by Scuzzer

Would be a waste of time down at Portman Road...cant decipher anything over that PA.


That is another valid reason it's not viable across the sport.

Jumpers for goalposts won't exist one day.

Poll: By only voting with your head and not heart, will we stay up?

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 20:21 - Jan 10Swansea_Blue

He’s at that age where everything was wonderful in the olden days. He’s miles off the mark if he thinks that before VAR we never debated or over-analysed offside, handballs or holding in the box. We did nothing but!

He’s not right about the general view of VAR either. A lot seem against it.

He is right that there’s a lot of confusion, but that’s got nothing to do with VAR. It’s the constant changes to the laws of the game and lack of consistency in how they are applied. I’ve just watched the highlights and Bergvallā€˜s second challenge is a yellow 99 times out of a hundred. He took the guy out on the break, missing the ball completely. That should be a yellow. To have rules that says it’s not because advantage was played (in Liverpool’s own half) is a nonsense. Sure, let it go, but it has to be pulled back imo otherwise you’ve got two separate interpretations of the same foul allowed. So it’s the rules that are creating the confusion - nothing to do with VAR. And we’d still be talking about it if VAR didn’t exist.

Not at all surprised to see Atwell’s name crop up. He’s never far from controversy!
[Post edited 10 Jan 2025 20:23]

Poll: Escaped Goat of the day. Who’s it going to be?

1
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 20:27 - Jan 10Swansea_Blue

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 17:22 - Jan 9 by homer_123

No Ange, it's not what the people want, it never, ever, ever was.

OK, let me re-phrase. It's not what the fans wanted.

Might be wanted by those in charge of football.


I wanted it, in some form. There were far too many missed decisions that sometimes had major implications for teams. Video referrals work well in some other sports. The trouble is that we’ve got the same incompetents manning VAR and the rules are a bit of a mess.

Poll: Escaped Goat of the day. Who’s it going to be?

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 23:46 - Jan 10BanksterDebtSlave

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:21 - Jan 9 by Dubtractor

Read that earlier and agreed with most of it. Especially the bit about how odd it is that people are getting excited about the ref speaking over the pa system!


Maybe what we need is to spread the game over four quarters lest we get over excited and miss valuable advertising opportunities.

"They break our legs and tell us to be grateful when they offer us crutches."
Poll: What you watching.

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 00:39 - Jan 11sotd78

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 23:46 - Jan 10 by BanksterDebtSlave

Maybe what we need is to spread the game over four quarters lest we get over excited and miss valuable advertising opportunities.


Add in multi ball while you're about it. We're nearly there with balls on cones. Best game this soccer ... so much faster than football. Lol.

Blue shirts/white shorts - sotd78

0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 06:56 - Jan 11ibbleobble

He’s largely right. Regarding the Bergvall incident, he wasn’t lucky to be on the pitch as his first yellow wasn’t one, so in the words of KM, ā€œthese things even outā€.

The game feels like it’s now accommodating tech for change sake when it was first introduced to make positive change. I think we can all agree, it’s been a failure so I’m with Ange - leave the game alone, sport is great for its inconsistencies as much as it is its consistency. Sport without error or misjudgement veers more towards sterility.
0
Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 07:59 - Jan 11TractorWood

Postecoglou's tirade on 'change' on 15:22 - Jan 9 by Guthrum

'We never used to debate offsides, we never used to debate handballs, we never used to debate holding in the box, we never used to debate so many things.' Has he ever talked to any fans, or read old interviews? Managers have been moaning about decisions going against them since time immemorial. VAR has just given them a new layer of officials to complain about when they don't get what they want.


Maradona's handball is brought up every tournament.

As is Lampard's non goal.

VAR is imo positive overall as its broadly ensures these grave miscarriages of footballing justice can't happen. However, as football is both inherently judgmental, endlessly analysed and chaotically random the smaller decisions often trigger immense debate as it is perceived to impact the broader game.

The game is excessively surgical. Tbh I saw it was league cup and was immediately disinterested.
[Post edited 11 Jan 2025 8:05]

I know that was then, but it could be again..
Poll: At present who do you think you'll vote for?

0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2026