Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
Forum index | Previous Thread | Next thread
For all the good we’ve done with signings… 17:59 - Aug 13 with 3361 viewsSitfcB

…over the last few years there still hasn’t half been some absolute bizarre ones/flops.

R. Harper
G. Ahadme
A. Al-Hamadi
A. Muric

(The main ones off the top of my head but sure there’s 2 or 3 more?)

Is it to be expected with the amount of signings we make?

They aren’t all going to be a Morsy or a Chaplin I suppose but it’s beggars belief we’ve made these ones, especially Muric, based on some stats, going up to the Premier League and we made a mistake like that.

All the aforementioned really key areas as well, maybe with the exclusion of Harper as he was just ‘back up’ anyway.

COYB
Poll: Should we block polls for one day?
Blog: [Blog] One Year On

0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:04 - Aug 13SheffordBlue

I think there are some different types in there:

Harper - just a product of the demolition man summer
Ahadme (and maybe Camara) - relatively cheap options to fill a gap when we didn't land a main target. Kept the majority of our money for other options in the following window. Some of these types worked out really well - e.g the Luongo deal was a cheap short term option that went so much better than many thought it would
Al-Hamadi - was viewed as us jumping a march on some clubs higher up. If we'd had the squad depth the sort of signing we might buy and look to loan out early to develop whilst we still owned him.
Muric - good on paper, bad in practice - seems like some warning signs were missed here.

Poll: What % of our full potential are we currently playing at?

0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:05 - Aug 13parkinshair

Panutche Camará

Its all eggs, baked beans, and a fried slice
Blog: A New Hope Has Quickly Turned into Carry On Screaming

0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:06 - Aug 13J2BLUE

Ahadme was a punt. We tried to do other deals which didn't come off so took a punt. Some will call it a panic signing. Whatever.

Al-Hamadi wasn't random. He was one the fans were excited about. We just rose too quickly for him. He's a victim of our success.

Muric looked a good signing at the time. Not all signings work out.
1
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:06 - Aug 13ArnoldMoorhen

We made a profit on Ahadme, so under the player trading model, he wasn't a flop.

We might make a profit on Ali Al Hamadi, so the same would apply to him.

Neither were bought to be the first choice Centre Forward.

Muric was such a wrong signing. His clangers cost us not just points, but also the momentum and belief that we could survive.

Harper feels ages ago! Was he an Ashton signing?!?!?
1
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:09 - Aug 13StNeotsBlue

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:06 - Aug 13 by ArnoldMoorhen

We made a profit on Ahadme, so under the player trading model, he wasn't a flop.

We might make a profit on Ali Al Hamadi, so the same would apply to him.

Neither were bought to be the first choice Centre Forward.

Muric was such a wrong signing. His clangers cost us not just points, but also the momentum and belief that we could survive.

Harper feels ages ago! Was he an Ashton signing?!?!?


Regarding Harper, he and Edwards were the beginning of the West Brom invasion.
[Post edited 13 Aug 2025 18:09]
-1
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:10 - Aug 13waveneyblue

Not disagreeing with you, but I think you can look at most clubs and say the same thing.

Our sister bothering neighbours up the road are a great example. They've bought some right sh1te, some for decent money.

It happens, you kiss a lot of frogs before you find a prince.
2
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:10 - Aug 13Illinoisblue

Wonder if we’re still tied to the multi year contract/agreement with the analytics arm of goalkeeper.com. Announced about this time last summer.

Notably, it appears no other clubs have signed up to work with them in such a way.

62 - 78 - 81
Poll: What sport is the most corrupt?

0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:20 - Aug 13SitfcB

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:05 - Aug 13 by parkinshair

Panutche Camará


Yeah and him.

COYB
Poll: Should we block polls for one day?
Blog: [Blog] One Year On

0
Login to get fewer ads

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 19:17 - Aug 13SitfcB

Scott Fraser another.

COYB
Poll: Should we block polls for one day?
Blog: [Blog] One Year On

1
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 19:20 - Aug 13vilanovablue

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:05 - Aug 13 by parkinshair

Panutche Camará


Was intrigued when we signed him but the fact we signed him injured made it a waste of time as he never really recovered.
0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 19:27 - Aug 13vilanovablue

Show me a side with a perfect transfer record, we've had a huge amount of churn accommodating our rise.
0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 19:40 - Aug 13bluesym

Kalvin Phillips,big risk and a big flop.

Poll: Is Micheal Mcintyre actually funny?

0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:02 - Aug 13Re_User

To be fair to Ahadme, he had an excellent game against our centre halves for Burton just before he signed, and he was still relatively young, despite not meeting the grade at Pompey. One of those that turned out to be playing at his level, rather than having potential.
0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:13 - Aug 13ArnieM

I think k Town coukd sign the best 11 players in the world and we'd still struggle as we currently do simply because McKenna will not adapt and change his approach ( formation). He insists of making players conform to his tactics rather than play players to their strengths and in their best/ most effective position, and in the best combinations, but he will not change
Our opponents know hiw we are going to play because McKenna never changes, even when its clearly not working. How many more games are we going to be overrun or outnumbered in midfield before he changes his formation?

Little wonder our forward line us so ineffective when it gets bu gger all service, or our defence is back peddling because the MF is steamrollered!

The manager is in danger of coming across as a one trick pony. He needs to learn, adapt change. I just cant believe a deep thinker like him isn't reflecting on the last 12 months and trying something else.

Poll: Would this current Town team beat the current narwich team

0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:15 - Aug 13bournemouthblue

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 19:40 - Aug 13 by bluesym

Kalvin Phillips,big risk and a big flop.


Throw Godfrey into that mix

Alcohol is the answer but I can't remember the question!
Poll: How much for Omari

2
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:19 - Aug 13FrimleyBlue

Thing is, our recruitment based on stats, doesn't appear to be going well compared to what you can assume prior was actually watching and researching players or managing them before

If you look at recent high stat signings, they aren't pulling up trees for us as yet
Sammy S, Jack Clarke, Muric as you mention, ( But then we were missing Brightons data.. did we simply look at champ stats and try for the best players? )

When we recruited the likes of broady, Davis etc, their stats weren;t amazing, but they had talent that could work with km's football, not many signings since look to fit KM's football which for me is a bizarre strategy. Oshea is a solid signing, but when think of KM football does he suit it? same with greaves, same with palmer really. All high stat players in certain areas but not really players who i feel are km players.

Waka Waka
Poll: We've had Kuqi v Pablo.. so Broadhead or Celina?
Blog: Marcus Evans Needs Our Support Not to Be Hounded Out

1
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:22 - Aug 13BarcaBlue

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:13 - Aug 13 by ArnieM

I think k Town coukd sign the best 11 players in the world and we'd still struggle as we currently do simply because McKenna will not adapt and change his approach ( formation). He insists of making players conform to his tactics rather than play players to their strengths and in their best/ most effective position, and in the best combinations, but he will not change
Our opponents know hiw we are going to play because McKenna never changes, even when its clearly not working. How many more games are we going to be overrun or outnumbered in midfield before he changes his formation?

Little wonder our forward line us so ineffective when it gets bu gger all service, or our defence is back peddling because the MF is steamrollered!

The manager is in danger of coming across as a one trick pony. He needs to learn, adapt change. I just cant believe a deep thinker like him isn't reflecting on the last 12 months and trying something else.


You've never liked McKenna, have you? I mean 2 promotions in 2 seasons suggests he has more than a clue about what he's doing but I'm sure also appreciates your advice and insight.
2
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:24 - Aug 13PacittiJohn

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:13 - Aug 13 by ArnieM

I think k Town coukd sign the best 11 players in the world and we'd still struggle as we currently do simply because McKenna will not adapt and change his approach ( formation). He insists of making players conform to his tactics rather than play players to their strengths and in their best/ most effective position, and in the best combinations, but he will not change
Our opponents know hiw we are going to play because McKenna never changes, even when its clearly not working. How many more games are we going to be overrun or outnumbered in midfield before he changes his formation?

Little wonder our forward line us so ineffective when it gets bu gger all service, or our defence is back peddling because the MF is steamrollered!

The manager is in danger of coming across as a one trick pony. He needs to learn, adapt change. I just cant believe a deep thinker like him isn't reflecting on the last 12 months and trying something else.


Agree wholeheartedly with this post. I am really confused by McKenna at the moment. One of those that thought he was initially brilliant (especially when compared to all those “managers” that followed Magilton), but his inflexibility is becoming a problem, and I’m also starting to doubt his man management skills.
-2
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:25 - Aug 13Alberto_the_frog

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 18:20 - Aug 13 by SitfcB

Yeah and him.


Piggott

Poll: Should ITFC leave x?

0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:26 - Aug 13TripSwitch

For the money spent, Jack Clarke is right at the top of this list

Poll: What rating out of 10 do you give to Ipswichs season up to this point?

-2
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:26 - Aug 13positivity

we could turn a profit on 3 of those (though i'll believe it when i see it for aro!), so if they're the worst, then we're doing pretty well!

hardly wolfswinkie levels of flop...

Poll: do you do judo and/or do you do voodoo?

0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:27 - Aug 13Vic

Dont look at Alex Fergusons or Wengers list od signings then! Many, many that didnt work out at Man u ir Arsenal. No one gets them all right. Nothing unusual.

Poll: Will you be watching the 3rd/4th place play off game?

1
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:28 - Aug 13ArnieM

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:22 - Aug 13 by BarcaBlue

You've never liked McKenna, have you? I mean 2 promotions in 2 seasons suggests he has more than a clue about what he's doing but I'm sure also appreciates your advice and insight.


Well, you couldnt be more wrong there. I think hes an outstanding young manager. But I'm just perplexed that he doesnt change and adapt.

There seems to be a problem with so many people on here that its seen as a crime to ask or pose questions and challenge things instead of following blindly.

Poll: Would this current Town team beat the current narwich team

0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:31 - Aug 13DarkBrandon

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 19:40 - Aug 13 by bluesym

Kalvin Phillips,big risk and a big flop.


Risk?
0
For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:39 - Aug 13bluesym

For all the good we’ve done with signings… on 20:31 - Aug 13 by DarkBrandon

Risk?


Yeah,a risk. What would you call it?

Poll: Is Micheal Mcintyre actually funny?

0
About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2026