| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? 21:26 - Nov 14 with 1545 views | GlasgowBlue | Amazing to watch. |  |
| |  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 22:19 - Nov 14 | SitfcB | How much pollution does one of them cause? |  |
|  |
| 21%. (n/t) on 22:43 - Nov 14 | Bloots |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 22:19 - Nov 14 by SitfcB | How much pollution does one of them cause? |
|  |
| Serial upvoter and TWTD Legend. |
|  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 22:53 - Nov 14 | BanksterDebtSlave |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 22:19 - Nov 14 by SitfcB | How much pollution does one of them cause? |
I didn't see it but I did just see the most incredible fireball meteor from the Taurid shower, way better I imagine. |  |
| "They break our legs and tell us to be grateful when they offer us crutches." | | Poll: | What you watching. |
|  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 22:55 - Nov 14 | stonojnr | its epoch defining in spaceflight terms. |  | |  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 23:04 - Nov 14 | Bigalhunter |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 22:50 - Nov 14 by Perublue | Get back in your damp cave you Neanderthal…otherwise you may discover the internet to moan on. |
This internet you speak of…expand please.. |  |
|  | Login to get fewer ads
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 23:27 - Nov 14 | Bigalhunter |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 23:06 - Nov 14 by Sarge | The world is completely reliant on space capability and Starship and SpaceX are vital to some of the large in-space construction projects that are planned. Elon Musk might be a tit but SpaceX is what a lot of the space industry is counting on for launch platforms |
‘The world is completely reliant on space capability’ As a bewildered and sceptical old man, explain… |  |
|  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 00:07 - Nov 15 | Sarge |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 23:27 - Nov 14 by Bigalhunter | ‘The world is completely reliant on space capability’ As a bewildered and sceptical old man, explain… |
Everything that relies on positional data or a timing signal (GPS, financial systems, stock markets, power grids and energy systems, aircraft navigation, emergency services, and so on) is reliant on space to get that data. Everything that relies on telecoms aside from radio broadcasts (so TV signals, phone calls and so on) is reliant on space capability. If we lost everything from space for one day you’d be surprised at how many normal things you couldn’t do. And the financial cost would be astronomical. I work in the space industry, specifically in the defence of space assets. They are quietly underpinning every part of critical national infrastructure, largely unbeknownst to the public and as such are a massive target to adversaries who can conduct below-threshold warfare (that is, not an overt military attack) by degrading or disrupting signals from space long enough to be annoying. |  | |  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 04:21 - Nov 15 | Ryorry |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 00:07 - Nov 15 by Sarge | Everything that relies on positional data or a timing signal (GPS, financial systems, stock markets, power grids and energy systems, aircraft navigation, emergency services, and so on) is reliant on space to get that data. Everything that relies on telecoms aside from radio broadcasts (so TV signals, phone calls and so on) is reliant on space capability. If we lost everything from space for one day you’d be surprised at how many normal things you couldn’t do. And the financial cost would be astronomical. I work in the space industry, specifically in the defence of space assets. They are quietly underpinning every part of critical national infrastructure, largely unbeknownst to the public and as such are a massive target to adversaries who can conduct below-threshold warfare (that is, not an overt military attack) by degrading or disrupting signals from space long enough to be annoying. |
So, a huge array of stuff we now rely on in daily life is dependent on space tech and A I. The same space tech and AI which also has the capacity to destroy it … Good old pen and paper, and analogue landline phones - boomers’ backups :) If anyone didn’t see amd wasn’t already awareo. the second half content of C4’s lengthy documentary on Thurs evening on the development of AI confirmed how extraordinarily stupid & selfish musk is, AI wiping out humankind? “No problem, we’ll move to Mars”. But, his underlings point out (as everyone on here would) - if AI can do that on this planet, then surely it could do that on the next planet we occupy too? “Oh, errr, I hadn’t thought of that” goes the ‘genius’ … |  |
|  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 08:18 - Nov 15 | Swansea_Blue |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 23:06 - Nov 14 by Sarge | The world is completely reliant on space capability and Starship and SpaceX are vital to some of the large in-space construction projects that are planned. Elon Musk might be a tit but SpaceX is what a lot of the space industry is counting on for launch platforms |
Like Starlink to protect vulnerable countries from attacks by neighbours? (The point being it’s not the technology that’s the issue, but those who control it). [Post edited 15 Nov 8:41]
|  |
|  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 15:21 - Nov 15 | Bluespeed225 | It's what Gerry Anderson told me the future would be! Musk should send one with a mock up of Tracy Island around the launch pad. |  | |  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 15:21 - Nov 15 | bsw72 |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 00:07 - Nov 15 by Sarge | Everything that relies on positional data or a timing signal (GPS, financial systems, stock markets, power grids and energy systems, aircraft navigation, emergency services, and so on) is reliant on space to get that data. Everything that relies on telecoms aside from radio broadcasts (so TV signals, phone calls and so on) is reliant on space capability. If we lost everything from space for one day you’d be surprised at how many normal things you couldn’t do. And the financial cost would be astronomical. I work in the space industry, specifically in the defence of space assets. They are quietly underpinning every part of critical national infrastructure, largely unbeknownst to the public and as such are a massive target to adversaries who can conduct below-threshold warfare (that is, not an overt military attack) by degrading or disrupting signals from space long enough to be annoying. |
95% of internet traffic is terrestrial via undersea cables, in fact domestic traffic is almost entirely terrestrial fibre and mobile networks. Impact is indirect rather than a direct link on satellite. Satellite's role is coverage rather than volume: remote areas, ships, aircraft, disaster recovery and backup links where laying fibre isn't practical. The indirect dependency is primarily the time element with the reliance of NTP servers on satellite time feed, but even they have terrestrial backups which would work for a couple of days. I think your point on dependency is right, but the impact would be really felt after 2-3 days rather than on the first day. |  | |  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 15:39 - Nov 15 | mellowblue |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 04:21 - Nov 15 by Ryorry | So, a huge array of stuff we now rely on in daily life is dependent on space tech and A I. The same space tech and AI which also has the capacity to destroy it … Good old pen and paper, and analogue landline phones - boomers’ backups :) If anyone didn’t see amd wasn’t already awareo. the second half content of C4’s lengthy documentary on Thurs evening on the development of AI confirmed how extraordinarily stupid & selfish musk is, AI wiping out humankind? “No problem, we’ll move to Mars”. But, his underlings point out (as everyone on here would) - if AI can do that on this planet, then surely it could do that on the next planet we occupy too? “Oh, errr, I hadn’t thought of that” goes the ‘genius’ … |
who needs GPS, get your old road maps out. |  | |  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 17:34 - Nov 15 | AbBlue | Is it? Yeah, technically it's obviously great but to compare to the Shuttle coming in to land it feels to me as if we've regressed. |  | |  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 18:07 - Nov 15 | Swansea_Blue |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 17:34 - Nov 15 by AbBlue | Is it? Yeah, technically it's obviously great but to compare to the Shuttle coming in to land it feels to me as if we've regressed. |
When you look at it that way, then yes we’re further back than we were 45 years ago. Crazy to think that’s the case when we’ve had a an age of phenomenal technological development in the meantime. I assume it’s cost that put the kibosh on space missions? |  |
|  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 18:25 - Nov 15 | StokieBlue |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 18:07 - Nov 15 by Swansea_Blue | When you look at it that way, then yes we’re further back than we were 45 years ago. Crazy to think that’s the case when we’ve had a an age of phenomenal technological development in the meantime. I assume it’s cost that put the kibosh on space missions? |
Whilst this might seem like what's happened, it's not really true. The shuttle, whilst looking impressive was actually a bit of a trick. Yes it landed like a plane but all the tiles on the shuttle had to be replaced every mission and the booster tanks were completely new ones every mission. The cost of a shuttle launch over it's lifetime was ~1.5bn USD. Landing a rocket (booster and upper stage) vertically so it's entirely reusable is a far more difficult technical challenge than gliding down from orbit and then replacing lots of pieces. Also worth considering that Starship is absolutely huge compared to the shuttle and carries far more payload (x4 to x8 what the shuttle could carry depending on proposed versions and configurations). The Falcon Heavy which has already flown and landed (11 times) and carries approximately twice what the shuttle could manage and at a cost between x20-35 cheaper per KG. SB |  |
| Avatar - M101 - Pinwheel Galaxy |
|  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 18:59 - Nov 15 | Swansea_Blue |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 18:25 - Nov 15 by StokieBlue | Whilst this might seem like what's happened, it's not really true. The shuttle, whilst looking impressive was actually a bit of a trick. Yes it landed like a plane but all the tiles on the shuttle had to be replaced every mission and the booster tanks were completely new ones every mission. The cost of a shuttle launch over it's lifetime was ~1.5bn USD. Landing a rocket (booster and upper stage) vertically so it's entirely reusable is a far more difficult technical challenge than gliding down from orbit and then replacing lots of pieces. Also worth considering that Starship is absolutely huge compared to the shuttle and carries far more payload (x4 to x8 what the shuttle could carry depending on proposed versions and configurations). The Falcon Heavy which has already flown and landed (11 times) and carries approximately twice what the shuttle could manage and at a cost between x20-35 cheaper per KG. SB |
Fair enough, I suppose if this all progresses it gives the greater capacity. And is vastly superior technologically and bvalue. I was thinking more about the ability to pilot missions to space and return under our own steam that’s not progressed, rather than the tech. This is catching up with a capacity we used to have (albeit vastly different tech and potential applications). Trouble is, who’s going to trust Musk and SpaceX, but that’s a separate issue lol |  |
|  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 19:13 - Nov 15 | mellowblue |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 18:59 - Nov 15 by Swansea_Blue | Fair enough, I suppose if this all progresses it gives the greater capacity. And is vastly superior technologically and bvalue. I was thinking more about the ability to pilot missions to space and return under our own steam that’s not progressed, rather than the tech. This is catching up with a capacity we used to have (albeit vastly different tech and potential applications). Trouble is, who’s going to trust Musk and SpaceX, but that’s a separate issue lol |
NASA trusts them, they are not getting to the moon without using SpaceX. |  | |  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 19:23 - Nov 15 | mellowblue |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 17:34 - Nov 15 by AbBlue | Is it? Yeah, technically it's obviously great but to compare to the Shuttle coming in to land it feels to me as if we've regressed. |
The shuttle was very limited in what it could achieve, taxi/supply service for the space station, transport satellites for launching etc. It could only operate in low earth orbit, roughly upto 400 miles from earth. The planned missions for starship are a lot more ambitious. |  | |  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 19:43 - Nov 15 | stonojnr | Just to show space is hard, ULA report the loss of their Vulcan rocket (technically the Centaur stage of it) 10mins into launch, full loss of payload. |  | |  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 19:52 - Nov 15 | Swansea_Blue |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 19:13 - Nov 15 by mellowblue | NASA trusts them, they are not getting to the moon without using SpaceX. |
There seems a bit of friction - https://theconversation.com/wh Although this capture will no doubt help SpaceX. We’ll see what way the wind blows if when the administration changes. I wouldn’t trust Musk as far as I could throw him. |  |
|  |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 20:18 - Nov 15 | Sarge |
| Did anyone just see the Space X rocket "catch"? on 19:52 - Nov 15 by Swansea_Blue | There seems a bit of friction - https://theconversation.com/wh Although this capture will no doubt help SpaceX. We’ll see what way the wind blows if when the administration changes. I wouldn’t trust Musk as far as I could throw him. |
You need to make the distinction between what Musk says and does and what SpaceX as a whole does. He is in a desperate race to put himself on the worst people in history list for some reason and seems to have considerable sway over Starlink access in Ukraine to play some crackhead version of Risk. Probably because he’s a try hard loser with nothing else to do. However SpaceX have fundamentally changed the game in Space, they’ve lowered the cost of launch such that huge projects like space based solar power, in-space manufacturing, and Starlink are now feasible. No national governments can afford to do much in Space and no other private company even comes close to SpaceX. Their technology and reputation in the industry is streets ahead of anyone else. Not to mention that the closest challengers are also run by degenerates like Jeff Bezos. No government of any colour is ever going to rip up that. It would be far easier just to force Musk out somehow. The same is true of Trump and the US military under him. Despite the crap he spouts at a public level, behind the scenes the US/UK/NATO/FVEY militaries work together like we always have. It’s what makes some of the comments I’ve seen recently laughable, like stopping intel sharing with the US or kicking them out of Five Eyes like it’s any kind of equitable relationship and they don’t bring 99% of it themselves. It’s like telling the only person with a ball he can’t play and should go home. Summary: the sh1theads that head up these companies and governments differ from the actual work that their companies/departments do even though sometimes they can bend them to their will like Starlink in Ukraine. |  | |  |
| |