Please log in or register. Registered visitors get fewer ads.
McKenna: PGMOL Has Admitted We Should Have Had Two Penalties
Monday, 9th Mar 2026 10:11

Town boss Kieran McKenna says the PGMOL, the body which manages referees, has admitted the Blues should have been awarded two penalties during Saturday’s 1-1 home draw with Leicester City.

Anis Mehmeti was tripped when turning away from Harry Winks in the 56th minute but referee John Busby waved away the protests.

Town had an even more clear-cut spot-kick denied by the official in the dying seconds when Hamza Choudhury bundled Cedric Kipre to the floor as a Dara O’Shea cross came in from the right.

McKenna was unusually forthright in his post-match comments, the referee, who had also denied the Blues two penalties in the final minutes of the 1-1 draw with Preston, having said he hadn’t seen the Kipre incident.

The Blues boss was asked whether the frustrations had died down since Saturday.

“Not just about the penalties, of course,” he said. “We want to win every game, especially a home game, so we’re frustrated that we didn’t manage to do that in all capacities. 

“I think we’ve done enough in the game to win it, certainly, but we gave away a set play goal. It’s probably only a half-chance, but it was a really good finish. We weren’t clinical with our set plays or with enough of our chances in free play.

“Of course, we all know those bits, but also, there’s no getting away from it, for me, watching them back and having clarity from the officials now, they were two clear penalties. 

“One that’s an absolute 100 per cent penalty that we should have been a kick to win the game, and then it could be really different.

“We’re frustrated that we didn’t get to win, but we also know there are positives out there in the performance and there’s no time to dwell, either way.

“We just move on now quickly to Stoke. We’ll train well and prepare as well as we can, and try to get a good performance tomorrow night.”

McKenna says his assistant Martyn Pert spoke to former referee Kevin Friend, who is now the manager of Select Group 2 officials.

“Martyn spoke to Kevin Friend, who conducts that at this level,” he added. “Martyn and him caught up yesterday and there’s a full admission that there should have been two penalties, one on Anis and certainly the one at the end. They’re disappointed from the officials that it wasn’t given. Of course, it doesn’t change anything now.”

Traditionally the view is that these things even themselves out over the course of the season.

“I think we’re going to need some pretty good evidence in the next 11 games for that to be the case!” McKenna smiled ruefully.

“I try and stay pragmatic about it and control what we can control. I’ve said before, I’m not the first one to be shouting about VAR and things like that, so if you’re not in that camp then you don’t want to be hypocritical and be screaming for every decision.

“But there are some that really, really disappoint you beyond the norm of ’anyone can make a mistake, it’s a hard job’ and that was one of them, and it was such a pivotal point in the game and not a particularly difficult decision.

“I think that was more disappointing than most. But one thing we certainly can’t afford is that that decision drags on in our mood or our morale or anything like that.

“There are things to learn from the game, certainly positives to take and it’s about how we quickly turn our mindset to Tuesday night that’s going to be the most important thing this week.”

Town have shown in recent weeks that they can come back from adversity, having won three in a row after the back-to-back FA Cup and Championship defeats at Wrexham and are now four matches without a loss as disappointing as Saturday’s stalemate was.

“It’s not always about a reaction,” McKenna reflected. “I understand why it is, but it’s not always about a reaction.

“It’s not like tomorrow night now is a reaction to the game, it’s 46 games, you’re not going to play well or win every one.

“We got a disappointing result at Wrexham, it’s one of our losses this season and then we had to regroup and just get back to doing what we do well. 

“That’ll be the same case for this. I think, in general, our form is good, we want and maybe need it to be even better than good.

“And the only way to do that is focusing on the next game and delivering performances and trying to find the margin to get you the results, and the next chance to do that is Tuesday.”

Photo: TWTD



Please report offensive, libellous or inappropriate posts by using the links provided.



PortmanTerrorist added 10:19 - Mar 9
That ref is getting off lightly. To say he did not see it, is completely unbelievable....he was in our eyeline behind the foul at the end with nothing between him and was plenty close enough too. I can accept he is not corrupt as some idiots are suggesting, but the evidence suggests that in both games he has 'officiated' that he simply cannot handle a big game/Club and should not referee at this level again for a long time, if ever he proves worthy in the future.
31

OldFart71 added 10:42 - Mar 9
No good crying over spilled milk as they say. But I have watched the replay several times and concluded this referee is a liar. He was looking straight at the incident involving Kipre.
The game is turning into a farce where VAR is ruining Premier League game where the excitement of your team scoring a goal is taken away by waiting for offsides where a players toenail is offside, where on some occasions a player is deemed interfering with the sight of the keeper and exactly the same happens in another game and the player isn't.
Then we have referees allowed to get away with not seeing obvious penalties in the Championship and in the main being of poor quality. Constantly interrupting games by giving free kicks and allowing teams to waste time.
13

ringwoodblue added 10:47 - Mar 9
If we don’t achieve a top two finish, this denial of penalties and the resulting scoreline against Leicester won’t be the only reason. Losing to Charlton and Oxford will be more significant.
7

Brogan55 added 11:00 - Mar 9
It would be a gesture from the Ref to concede that he made a mistake.But that is not how it is done.They hide or say they didn’t see it.
I still remember Clive Thomas ruling out Bryan Hamilton’s goal against West Ham in the semi final of the FACup.What a prat.Although years later he did concede he got it wrong.
10

poet added 11:06 - Mar 9
It’s a good outcome that this referee’s incompetence has been highlighted by his peers. However, the importance of the fact that he clearly was incompetent has sadly been overlooked. This referee’s incompetence most likely robbed Town of 2 valuable points. This could be detrimental towards our chances of promotion, and consequently have a severe financial impact on the clubs finances.

We all make mistakes, but the video shows a very accurate account of his ineptitude. So what punishment has been delved out to him? I suspect none. It’s about time referees are scrutinised for their actions and decisions, and if found to be falling short of the required performance, they should be punished.
I’ve no doubt despite his failings, he’ll still be paid, whilst Town could potentially lose many thousands of pounds due to his abysmal ans inexcusable decision making.
5

naa added 11:09 - Mar 9
ringwoodblue: don't forget the same ref stitched us up in the Preston game too (he was dreadful all round in that game).

Every team has off days, which Oxford and Charlton were (I still have no idea what happened against Charlton! We were the better team in the first half). So to pick out a bad performance or two and blaming the season on it doesn't really work.

Our problem this season wasn't those two games particularly, but a slow start that had us mid-table for too long. WE must be top two if you start the season from game 10. So a result here and there isn't the issue.

But when refs deny results it's just a bit more annoying!
7

SickParrot added 11:10 - Mar 9
PGMOL should be investigating why Mr Busby has failed to award us four obvious penalties this season. It can't be a deliberate bias against us, because he could have given a penalty against Davis in the first half, so they must be genuine mistakes. But how many other big errors like this has he made this season? When he doesn't see an incident does he consult his assistant? Does he need an eye test? Should he be allowed to referee us again?
7

Jugsy added 11:13 - Mar 9
I actually think the standard of reffing is pretty good in the Champ, most of the time. Mistakes are definitely there but they always have been presented and always should be, it's a game of perspectives and angles and it should be kept that way. Have we had any goals that should have been disallowed or argued about by the opposition? Have we conceded any contentious ones? I can't think of any but I bet you VAR would dredge footage to find reasons to disallow goals. Therefore, I'd say the officiating has generally been pretty good.

On the pens (Leicester and Preston), we can limit this to one official who seems to have a bit of a power complex. This is something for the PGMOL or whichever body to resolve. Because of changes in the game, linesmen/women have been disempowered over time, rather than helping the refs. They need to work better as a team for these decisions. Whilst the ref had the best angle, I find it hard to believe a linesman can't see it too.

McKenna, as always, has a measured and thought-out response to this. I disagree with ringwoodblue - football is a competition and you will lose games, those were lost those two fixtures on our merit, or lack of. However, Preston and Leicester were points dropped which we deserved to have, whereby we had done enough to encourage those fouls and create those opportunities. It's not a case of a bizarre view or angle catching the incident, it's a ref (same ref) missing clear fouls.
7

JPR77 added 11:13 - Mar 9
Totally with you, ringwoodblue — there are plenty of other matches this season where we simply weren’t good enough that could’ve been brought up as well. That said, if John Busby’s refereeing performances in our home games against Preston and Leicester were properly assessed, the PGMOL would either decide he isn’t up to officiating at any level, or assume he has some sort of issue with Ipswich. For everyone’s sake, it might be best to keep his appointments well away from Portman Road for the foreseeable.
0

BlueWax added 11:28 - Mar 9
The ref was looking straight at the Kipre incident, he states he didn't see it....he is a LIAR.

Blunt and to the point!
9

Steelmonkey added 11:28 - Mar 9
PGMOL (Professional Game Match Officials Limited) is the body responsible for training, developing, and appointing referees for all English professional football matches, including the Premier League, EFL, and FA competitions. Formed in 2001, it ensures consistent standards, manages over 160 officials, and is funded by the premier leagues and the FA
It’s not working is it?
1

MVBlue added 11:50 - Mar 9
So the lack of a clear penalty Versus Leicester in the Premiership denied us our first win and confidence in 2024. And the lack of a clear penalty Versus Leicester has taken the power out of our own hands for promotion in 2026. Bloody Leicester what the hell
3

Robert_Garrett added 11:52 - Mar 9
Once again its a case of many missed chances so there is no point rueing the sad fact that the referee was stunned by our inability to convert. Remember we could easily have MISSED the penalty even if we got one. The refs seem instructed not to give us penalties because we tend to dive a lot?
0

backwaywhen added 11:53 - Mar 9
Done and dusted we move on and hopefully 6 from the next 6 in the bag please .
1

HopefulBlue69 added 11:55 - Mar 9
In years gone by we used to be told that refs who made bad mistakes were demoted to lower league games (which were I guess were slower so easier to officiate). I doesn't rectify the 2 points lost but at least shows other officials that if the bottle tough decisions there will be consequences.....
3

Bazza8564 added 11:59 - Mar 9
I agree with Jugsy, the refs this season (apart from this one), have been Good. Swings and roundabouts , time to focus ahead and not back
1

Bert added 12:26 - Mar 9
The problem I believe is that certain referees, Busby in particular, have an attitude problem. These refs are very quick to issue cards as a means of stamping their authority on the game. On Saturday he gave cards to both teams that were minor fouls. He rarely talked to players. As for the penalties, Azon should stay on his feet but the other two were blatant fouls in the box. BUsby needs to be talked to and probably should be rested. However, I remain of the view that VAR is not the answer so I accept that mistakes will be made. Busby’s decisions were not just mistakes because he could clearly see the offences so he would appear to have lied.
5

Lightningboy added 12:31 - Mar 9
Busby should be struck off - end of.
2

Marshalls_Mullet added 12:34 - Mar 9
Lets move on. All footballers being cheats doesnt help the refs.

2

Northstandveteran added 12:35 - Mar 9
Luck evens itself out over a season.

We've had some decisions go our way regarding penalties in previous games.

This should be about VAR.

Personally, I think it spoils the flow of the game but Saturday we'd have been given a penalty or two.

0

Citynil added 13:23 - Mar 9
Forget Bus by, it should be Bus hi for him until he has retaken and passed his driving test.

I am assuming guide dogs are allowed on public transport.

If not, then I guess it’s taxi for Busby.
0

Broadbent23 added 13:25 - Mar 9
Are some Referees acting like Walter Mitties where their decisions can effect both promotion and relegation as in Saturday's game. Some will allow games to flow with niggly fouls and some will blow a whistle for nothing. Maybe it is time for AI (unlike VAR which is discussed via a panel) to be used and teams awarded bonus points if Referee standards have been seen to be broken. Football clubs are now a multi million pounds business and we now have paid officials on the pitch acting like Mr Magoo. Something has to change.


0

Carberry added 14:01 - Mar 9
No word from Ashton on this? Has he still got his head down?
-2

DavefromWatford added 14:11 - Mar 9
If the PGMOL have admitted the foul on Cedric was a penalty then surely his yellow card should be rescinded. Not that it helps us at all.
1

55015Deltic added 16:23 - Mar 9
Don’t agree you make your own goals you can’t blame the Referee as the players don’t help with all their diving and cheating. Yes Championship Referees are pretty poor but it’s the same for both Teams. Ipswich are as guilty as others for feigning injury I have to say….its the modern game they all copy each other.
-3


You need to login in order to post your comments

Blogs 297 bloggers

Ipswich Town Polls

About Us Contact Us Terms & Conditions Privacy Cookies Online Safety Advertising
© TWTD 1995-2026